Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Homes for Sale

Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Homes for Sale

$1,049,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Nestled along 75 feet of prime shoreline on beautiful Morse Reservoir, this exceptional waterfront home was designed for making memories. From morning coffee overlooking the water to unforgettable evening with family and friends, every outdoor space invites you to embrace lake living. A new Trex composite boardwalk (2025) leads to your private waterfront retreat featuring a covered Tiki Bar with swings, a spacious observation deck perfectly positioned for breathtaking sunsets, and a U-shaped dock with a metal roof complete with two boat lifts-a 6,000-pound HydroHoist and a 4,000-pound ShoreStation with electric motor and available vinyl cover. Wide steps provide easy access to the water, while electrical outlets along the boardwalk add convenience for entertaining and boating. The expansive concrete patio is an entertainer's dream, complete with 2 fire pits-one natural gas & one wood-burning-a covered pergola for year-round comfort, and ample space for gatherings. The oversized heated four-car garage, complete with a Reznor heating unit, has also served as an additional entertainment space. Extra parking accommodates 6-8 vehicles & plenty of room for boats and trailers. Inside, this thoughtfully designed 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath residence offers hardwood flooring throughout and a floor plan suited for everyday living & entertaining. 2 of the 4 bedrooms feature private en-suite baths. The kitchen is equipped with two sinks, two dishwashers, two garbage disposals, a dedicated prep sink. A Butler's Pantry provides storage and functionality for hosting. Upstairs, the conveniently located laundry room serves all bedrooms, while the primary suite offers a spacious walk-in closet with custom built-ins, skylights that fill the room with natural light, a natural gas hookup, and direct access to a screened porch structurally engineered to support a future hot tub. Upgrades : roof - 2017, water heater - 2022, concrete drive, walks & porch - 2024, Trex boardwalk - 2025

1080 Shoreline Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Yott Realty Group, LLC.

$699,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to your completely reimagined lakefront retreat at 1940 Nantucket Drive on the main body of Morse Reservoir! This stunning 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath home has been meticulously updated from top to bottom and sits on an expansive .38-acre corner lot with direct lake access and breathtaking water views. Step outside to your private boat dock featuring a canopy & electric boat lift, seawall installed (2016) has been freshly sealed, double-decker lakeside patios including lakeside fire pit, and a huge back deck with new stone wall accent-perfect for entertaining or watching sunsets over the lake. Inside, you'll find a move-in-ready masterpiece with a gorgeous updated kitchen boasting quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, soft close cabinets, and barstool seating. Brand-new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, built for durability. Three completely remodeled modern bathrooms. Updated primary suite w/ high end tile shower. Fresh interior & exterior paint; updated lighting and sheik boho style light fixtures. HVAC system updated in 2022, roof in 2021, for year-round comfort. Storage shed under back deck and built in shelves in the garage. New front steps and front door. Every detail has been thoughtfully refreshed while preserving the timeless charm of this classic lake house. Located less than 20 minutes to Grand Park and just a short walk to the neighborhood park w/ new pickleball courts and a quick golf-cart ride to everything downtown Cicero has to offer-restaurants like Red Bridge Bistro, shops, and seasonal events. No HOA and plenty of room for boats, trailers, toys, or even a future pool, this rare turn-key lakefront property combines modern luxury with the laid-back lake lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Big in all the right places: lakeside entertainment space, yard size & bed/bath count to enjoy w/ friends. Investors - Amazing AirBnB opportunity!

1940 Nantucket Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Canull Group LLC.

$384,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Fall in love with this updated cozy 3/2 home. Not sure what will catch your eye first; a morning coffee on the timber framed porch, a brand-new kitchen, and open floorplan located right across the street from Morse Reservoir and within walking distance to coffee shops, multiple restaurants, parks, and much more. Timber frame screened in porch added in 2021. Roofing, gutters, fascia, and soffit were all updated in 2022. New tankless water heater and water softener in 2023. New concrete patio added in 2025. Full kitchen remodel along with flooring in common areas in Dec. of 2025. New refrigerator, oven/ range, and dishwasher in Dec. of 2025. Multiple other updates throughout the home!

129 Bayshore Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Homes for Sale

Cicero Shores Real Estate

Cicero Shores is a neighborhood in Cicero, Indiana, located in Hamilton County within the Indianapolis metro area.

The listings and search results below are pulled live from the MLS, so you're seeing current, up-to-date homes for sale in Cicero Shores.

Our website features the best Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

View the Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Real Estate Market Report

Loading current market stats...

Curious about what’s happening in the Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold.

Want to know what homes in Cicero Shores are selling for? Check out the Cicero Shores, Cicero, IN Real Estate Market Report for current pricing trends and recent sales.