Refine Search
Sort by
4971 Benthaven Court, Bargersville
$817,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
KERRINGTON PROPER with Heated 16x32 Inground Pool on Large Fenced Cul De Sac Lot ~ 4300 SQFT BRICK RANCH & FINISHED BASEMENT featuring 5 BEDROOMS 3 BATHS Finished 3 CAR GARAGE & Everything you hope for in this versatile, custom floorplan: Open Concept, Smart Layout, Split Bedroom; MAIN~ GREAT ROOM: Vaulted Ceiling, Granite Masonry Gas Fireplace, 12' Custom Built in Bookshelves; Eat in KITCHEN: Custom Handmade Cabinets, Center Island, Granite Countertops, Stainless Steel Appliances including New Refrigerator 2026, & Newer Built-in Microwave, Soaring Ceiling, BREAKFAST NOOK; DINING ROOM: 15 ft Ceiling, Hardwood FLoor, Lots of Natural Light; MASTER: Exits to Screen Porch, His & Her Walk-in Closets, Sitting Area, Jetted Tub & Custom Separate Shower, Vanity galore w/ Dual Sinks; OFFICE: French Door; LAUNDRY: On main, Private, Custom Folding Station, Ceramic Tile Floor; BED 2 & 3: Excellent closet space, lighting, flooring; BASEMENT~ REC ROOM: Fenway Park "Green Monster" Replica on the wall, plush carpet; FAMILY ROOM: Theater/gaming area/comfy sectional couch & Entertaining Bar Area; BEDS 4 & 5: Great closet space, Egress windows; OUT: SCREENED LANAI PORCH, SWIMMING POOL - new in 2021, Wrought Iron Fence, Custom Landscape, NEW Concrete Curbing, 20 x 25 Basketball Court, Large Driveway with add'l parking; Cul De Sac, Great Neighbors, Sidewalk; ALSO: New Tankless Water Heater, Sprinkler System, Central Vac, Excellent Closet space & storage, Custom Finishes, Well Maintained & a tremendously active community - near the schools, the sports complexes, I 69, Bloomington Indy Airport, Bargersville's Lore, Walking Trails, Parks, Pickleball Courts, & More. Opportunity Knocks - Kerrington Proper in this price range.

4971 Benthaven Court, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Jeffrey Paxson. Jeff Paxson Team

Selling Office: eXp Realty LLC.

4874 Krestridge Court W, Bargersville
$825,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Experience exceptional craftsmanship in sought-after Kerrington Proper in Bargersville. This beautifully maintained ranch features light-filled living spaces, soaring ceilings, and an open-concept design with over 3,000 square feet and high-end finishes throughout. The gourmet kitchen features KitchenAid appliances, double ovens, a wine bar, and abundant storage. It flows seamlessly into the dining and living area making it perfect for entertaining and unwinding. The expansive primary suite offers a private retreat with a spa-like double shower and dual walk-in closets. A split floor plan provides two additional spacious bedrooms with jack and jill bathroom plus a flexible office/den or fourth bedroom. Outside, enjoy a three-car garage, built-in gas fire pit, and meticulously maintained landscaping. A rare opportunity to own a quality custom home designed for comfort, entertaining, and everyday luxury.

4874 Krestridge Court W, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Alexa Kitchen. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Selling Office: RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

4930 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville
$1,050,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Welcome to a truly one-of-a-kind residence, meticulously crafted by Jim Parsetich. This exceptional home offers over 5,400 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring 5 spacious bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and exquisite architectural details throughout-including soaring 12' ceilings, 8' doors, rich hardwood flooring, new plush carpet, and elegant painted wood trim. The gourmet kitchen boasts stunning granite countertops and connects to a light-filled four seasons room-perfect for year-round enjoyment. The fully finished basement is an entertainer's dream, complete with an additional primary suite offering privacy and comfort for guests or multi-generational living. Step outside into your own private resort-style oasis. The backyard is designed for unforgettable entertaining, showcasing an in-ground pool with a newly replaced liner and automatic cover, relaxing hot tub, and a fully equipped pool house featuring a half bath, outdoor shower, additional storage, and a large bar with dual sinks, garbage disposal, mini fridge, freezer, TV/stereo connections, gas hookup, and surround sound. Additional highlights include an expansive nearly 1,000 sq ft 3-car garage with epoxy floors, floor drains, two service doors, stairs to a large floored attic, and a backup generator for peace of mind. Every detail of this home reflects quality, comfort, and luxury-an extraordinary opportunity to own a Parsetich masterpiece.

4930 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Kathleen Kiel. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Selling Office: Ever Real Estate, LLC.

4931 Kerrington Boulevard, Bargersville
$950,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Amazing Custom 5-Bedroom Home with Pool & Finished Basement in Kerrington Proper! Located on a prime half-acre lot in one of the area's most desirable neighborhoods, this exceptional home offers luxury living inside and out. Step into an open, light-filled floor plan with hand-scraped bamboo hardwoods, elegant wainscoting, crown molding, and a spacious gourmet kitchen with a large center island. The great room features a cozy fireplace and flows seamlessly for easy entertaining. The main-level primary suite includes a luxurious bath, while the upper level offers four generously sized bedrooms and a 23x17 bonus room. The finished basement boasts raised ceilings, a family room with theater area, wet bar, rec room, exercise room, 5th bedroom, and full bath. Step outside to your private retreat-an oversized custom covered patio with cathedral ceiling, built-in grill, and a wood-burning fireplace overlooking the sparkling pool. A separate pool house with a storage room adds even more functionality and charm. Additional highlights include a formal dining room, private den, and a large 3-car garage. This is truly a one-of-a-kind opportunity in Kerrington Proper!

4931 Kerrington Boulevard, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Colleen Gordon. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Selling Office: Moving In Faith REALTORS, LLC.

4806 Krestridge Court E, Bargersville
$574,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Huge beautiful 2.63 acre lot on the lake with lake access. The house is a 3 bedroom 2 bath with great room and wonderful sunroom overlooking the lake and a 3 car garage with a work shop and plenty of shelves for storage.. The house needs some cosmetic updates, but is a solid brick ranch. Owner was a local builder with quality craftmanship. This property has been exempt from HOA in the covenants and restrictions, which was a requirement from this original owner as they owned the surrounding acreage that Kerrington Proper was developed in order to sell to the developer. New owners will have the option to join the HOA if desired, but not mandatory.

4806 Krestridge Court E, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of J. Marcos Torres. Torres Realty Alliance LLC

jmarcos.torres@comcast.net

Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

4890 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville
$900,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Luxury Living in Kerrington Proper! Welcome to 4890 Benthaven Dr E, a stunning custom-built residence nestled in the prestigious Kerrington Proper community. This beautifully crafted home offers the perfect blend of elegance, comfort, and entertainment, designed for those who appreciate both refined living and modern convenience. Step inside to soaring 15-foot cathedral ceilings that create an airy, grand ambiance throughout the main living area. An open-concept layout flows seamlessly into the gourmet kitchen and dining space, ideal for both intimate family dinners and lively gatherings. The floor-to-ceiling double-sided custom fireplace is a true show stopper! The main floor features the primary bedroom with gorgeous tray ceilings, custom tub and shower and walk-in closet. Two more spacious bedrooms can be found on the main level. Upstairs features another large bedroom along with a versatile bonus loft that provides the perfect space for a home office, playroom, or creative retreat. The basement is a true entertainer's dream: the finished walk-out basement features an additional bedroom, workout/bonus room, a state-of-the-art home theater with Dolby surround sound and a custom bar outfitted with commercial-grade bar equipment along with a rec room and family room, creating the ultimate setup for game days or movie nights. Step outside to your private oasis-an inviting swim spa offers year-round enjoyment, while the custom outdoor firepit creates the perfect backdrop for cozy evenings under the stars. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully curated for luxury and lifestyle. Located in a highly desirable neighborhood with access to top-rated schools and amenities, 4890 Benthaven Dr E is the total package. Don't miss your chance to own one of Kerrington Proper's most exceptional properties!

4890 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Emily Cordes. BluPrint Real Estate Group

emily@urbanindyhomes.com

Selling Office: HIVE Realty Group.

4884 E Krestridge Court E, Bargersville
$1,550,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
This custom-built luxury home in Kerrington Proper subdivision offers Center Grove schools and the perfect blend of elegance, comfort, and functionality. From the amazing water views to the thoughtful design elements, every detail of this home has been carefully planned to create the ultimate living experience. If you're looking for a home that truly stands out from the rest, this property is a must-see. From the main level with two ensuites and a home office to the lower level with a large family room and additional bedrooms, there is space for everyone in the family to enjoy. The elevator makes it easy for older family members to navigate the home, ensuring that everyone can live comfortably and independently. Step inside this luxury home and be greeted by amazing views of the water from every room. The gourmet chef's kitchen in this home is a dream for anyone who loves to entertain. With top-of-the-line appliances and ample counter space, you'll have everything you need to whip up delicious meals for family and friends. The adjacent sunroom, with heated flooring, provides the perfect spot to relax in any season. The main-level en-suite is a private oasis with access to the sunroom, two walk-in closets, and a spa-like bathroom. There is an additional en-suite on the mail level with a zero-entry shower that is perfect for older family members or guests who may have mobility issues. The lower level of this luxury home is perfect for family time, with a large family room, 2 additional bedrooms, 1 1/2 bathrooms and a spacious rec room that could easily be converted into a fifth bedroom. The theater room is ideal for movie nights, while the abundance of storage space ensures that you'll have plenty of room for all your belongings. Updates such as a new roof, plush carpet, refinished wood floors and modern appliances add to the charm and appeal of this stunning property.

4884 E Krestridge Court E, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Cindy Stockhaus. Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Gold Key

bhgoldkey@gmail.com

Selling Office: Cottingham Realty, Appraisal.

5802 Kerrington Ridge Court, Bargersville
$1,100,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths
Discover unparalleled luxury in this custom-built gem in Kerrington Proper. This exquisite 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom home seamlessly combines modern design with classic elegance. The heart of the home is the chef's kitchen, featuring high-end appliances, coffee station, a walk-in pantry, and a large island that's perfect for meal prep and entertaining. The main level includes a spacious master suite with a lavish en-suite bath w/ huge walk-in closet. Step into the grand living area with soaring coffered ceilings and abundant natural light. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms and a versatile loft space, ideal for a playroom or study. Also a dedicated office - ideal for those working from home. The full basement offers additional living space, including a fifth bedroom, a full bath, and a huge game room, perfect for family gatherings or hosting friends. The outdoor oasis features a pristine in-ground fiberglass saltwater pool, and a tree-lined yard that ensures privacy and tranquility. Enjoy outdoor activities on the basketball court or unwind on the covered front and back porches. Experience the pinnacle of comfort and privacy in this remarkable home-schedule your showing today!

5802 Kerrington Ridge Court, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Laurie Brown. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

lbrown@c21scheetz.com

Selling Office: Janko Realty Group.

4937 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville
$920,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Welcome to Kerrington Proper, where luxury meets serenity on over 1.2 acres of prestigious land. This magnificent multi-level residence boasts an amazing layout w/ over 6000 total square feet, perfect for versatile living. Indulge your culinary passions in the gourmet eat-in kitchen featuring a huge walk-in pantry, induction stove surrounded by a brick arch, and double oven. The hearth room, complete with a fireplace, offers a cozy retreat, while the spacious family room provides ample space for gatherings around another fireplace. Primary suite on the main level w/ a huge stand alone tub w/ huge walk-in shower Three additional bedrooms upstairs along with an amazing bonus room! Entertain in style at the basement bar or retreat to the wine cellar for a private tasting. Enjoy the family room to catch the Pacer game. Additional bedroom and full bath for guests or in-laws. Craft room and exercise room. Step outside to the covered back porch and unwind by the gas fire pit, surrounded by lush landscaping. Kerrington Proper epitomizes refined living at its finest.

4937 Benthaven Drive E, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Mark Linder. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

marklinderteam@c21scheetz.com

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

5876 Brockton Way, Bargersville
$1,165,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Welcome to 5876 Brockton Way, a spacious and thoughtfully designed home boasting an impressive 6351 square feet of living space. This property offers an exceptional lifestyle with 5 bedrooms (office is technical 6th) and 4.5 bathrooms, catering to a variety of living arrangements and needs. The heart of this home is its gourmet kitchen, equipped with a separate butler pantry with wine and beverage fridge, 5 burner gas range and pot filler, huge center island and eat-in breakfast room that is perfect for entertaining. The unique features such as the mudroom with a pocket door, multiple built-in benches and the convenience of having a laundry room on all 3 levels of this home cannot be overstated. The master suite is a private, tranquil, spa-like space housing a luxurious primary bath with walk-in shower with 3 showerheads, chandelier and a master closet designed for dressing to elevate the everyday experience. Upstairs, you will find large bedrooms with jack and jill bath and an awesome playroom. Outdoors, the covered deck extends your living space into the warmer months, overlooking a heated 16x34 saltwater pool with fountain feature and hot tub set against a private, wooded backyard for ultimate privacy and relaxation. The walkout basement includes a custom bar, bedroom, full bath, workout room and family room offering potential as in-law quarters or an expansive entertainment area. This home is the epitome of comfort, convenience, and luxury.

5876 Brockton Way, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Jenny Laughner. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

jenny@c21scheetz.com

Selling Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro S.

4955 Kerrington Boulevard, Bargersville
$757,478
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Welcome to luxury living in Kerrington Proper! Nestled in this prestigious community, this exquisite property offers the epitome of comfort, elegance, and functionality. As you step through the grand entrance foyer of this stunning brick and stone home, you're immediately greeted by the timeless allure of its design. The formal dining room awaits, providing the perfect setting for hosting memorable gatherings and entertaining guests. Continue your journey into the spacious living room/sitting room, where every detail exudes sophistication and warmth. Natural light floods the space, highlighting the impeccable craftsmanship and attention to detail throughout. Prepare to be amazed by the kitchen, a culinary enthusiast's dream come true. With ample storage, generous prep areas, and a seamless flow into the breakfast nook, this space is as practical as it is beautiful. Adjacent to the kitchen, you'll find a lovely family room, ideal for cozy nights in or casual get-togethers with loved ones. Retreat to the primary bedroom suite, a sanctuary of tranquility and relaxation. The spa-like bathroom features a luxurious shower stall and a garden tub, offering the perfect escape after a long day. The additional bedrooms are equally impressive, each boasting its own private bathroom and ample space for comfort and privacy. Convenience meets functionality in the expansive laundry room, catering to all your household needs with ease. Upstairs, a massive rec room awaits, offering endless possibilities as a home office, game room, or additional living space. Complete with a convenient half bath, this versatile area is limited only by your imagination. The unfinished basement presents a blank canvas, ready to be transformed into the ultimate entertainment area, home gym, or whatever your heart desires. Outside, indulge in resort-style living with a spacious patio and an inviting inground pool, perfect for enjoying the outdoors in style, along side a half length basketball court.

4955 Kerrington Boulevard, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Lindsey Smalling. F.C. Tucker Company

smallingeliterealtygroup@gmail.com

Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

5872 Kerrington Ridge Court, Bargersville
$880,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Beautiful custom built 5 BR, 4 BA home in prestigious Kerrington Proper! large open foyer, separate office w/ built-in bookshelves, open floor plan, kitchen/dining area. Updates include; new carpet, new landscaping and fresh paint throughout. Gourmet kitchen with granite counter-tops, stainless steel appliances & center island. Hard wood floors on main level, custom Mud room & upstairs laundry. Spacious master suite with sitting area, large master bath with shower, tub, dual sinks & large walk-in closet. 3 full baths upstairs- including a Jack/Jill. Covered porch area, complete with 22x40 salt water pool! 10' basement ceilings and 5th bedroom w/full bath. Do not miss your chance on this one!!!

5872 Kerrington Ridge Court, Bargersville

Listing courtesy of Amy Heidelberger. Keller Williams Indy Metro S

amy.h@kw.com

Selling Office: Trueblood Real Estate.

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!