Sign up to stay up to date on the Shelbyville, IN Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
2961 N 100 W 3 2 2,177 $280,000 $128 0 days
5918 N State Road 9 3 2 1,064 $239,900 $225 0 days
1043 Stratford Lane 3 2 1,294 $235,130 $181 1 day
2874 S Oakland Drive 3 1 1,000 $199,900 $199 2 days
422 W Mechanic Street 5 2 4,860 $249,900 $51 1 day
1370 Delacorte Circle 3 3 1,666 $259,000 $155 3 days
2419 Simpson Lane 3 2 1,498 $265,000 $176 4 days
858 Miller Avenue 3 1 1,053 $249,500 $236 5 days
1581 Crest Drive 3 2 1,604 $215,000 $134 7 days
1914 N 600 Road E 2 1 1,138 $100,000 $87 7 days
1904 Victor Higgins Drive 3 3 2,293 $324,990 $141 7 days
1816 Chinkapin Court 4 3 3,348 $264,900 $79 7 days
2237 Bear Oak Run 3 2 1,460 $294,990 $202 7 days
2379 Saddle Drive 2 2 1,205 $240,000 $199 7 days
910 Highpointe Boulevard 4 2 1,474 $229,900 $155 8 days
1401 Fox Ridge Drive 3 2 1,456 $246,000 $168 10 days
1215 W Washington Avenue 2 1 1,096 $25,000 $22 9 days
1126 Crestmoor Drive 3 1 912 $207,500 $227 10 days
1132 N Michigan Road 2 1 936 $199,900 $213 14 days
2209 S Miller Avenue 3 2 1,355 $230,000 $169 14 days
1032 Highpointe Boulevard 3 2 1,056 $209,000 $197 15 days
533 Lockerbie Road 3 2 2,776 $337,500 $121 16 days
532 E Timberbrook Estates 4 3 2,634 $319,900 $121 18 days
1370 E 225 S 4 2 1,776 $199,900 $112 18 days
1364 Ellington Drive 3 3 2,060 $239,000 $116 21 days
2113 Berwick Drive 3 2 1,425 $259,900 $182 31 days
410 Mary Street 3 1 2,682 $208,900 $77 21 days
1568 Culbertson Road 4 4 3,077 $399,000 $129 21 days
707 Westpointe Drive 3 2 1,233 $219,000 $177 22 days
2064 Black Oak Drive 4 3 1,598 $269,999 $168 22 days
1702 Wagner Drive 3 3 1,590 $215,000 $135 22 days
554 W Taylor Street 3 1 1,132 $179,900 $158 23 days
2014 Oak Leaf Way 4 3 2,140 $319,900 $149 24 days
2307 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,001 $314,990 $157 23 days
723 1st Street 2 1 1,382 $174,900 $126 24 days
2344 Marjorie Way 3 3 2,570 $344,990 $134 24 days
1041 W Hendricks Avenue 2 1 816 $164,900 $202 26 days
916 Congressional Way 4 3 1,564 $230,000 $147 26 days
131 2nd Street 3 2 2,794 $144,900 $51 25 days
1121 W Washington Avenue 2 1 1,472 $215,000 $146 28 days
151 2nd Street 2 2 2,421 $209,900 $86 26 days
933 Shelby Street 2 1 1,290 $141,000 $109 28 days
7554 E State Road 44 4 3 5,730 $350,000 $61 29 days
1110 Lincoln Street 2 1 816 $49,900 $61 29 days
1183 Aster Drive 5 3 2,600 $316,901 $121 30 days
2060 Black Oak Drive 3 2 1,350 $254,999 $188 32 days
2960 S Miller Street 3 2 1,688 $309,900 $183 33 days
931 E McKay Road 3 1 792 $185,000 $233 35 days
162 Habig Street 2 1 690 $112,000 $162 35 days
170 Habig Street 2 1 690 $112,000 $162 35 days
Average: 3.2 2.2 1,991 $258,353 $138 78 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 122
Viewing 1 - 50 of 122
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
2488 E Old Rushville Road 3 1 912 $175,000 $191 10 days
319 W Washington Street 4 3 4,494 $279,900 $62 15 days
2611 Berwick Drive 3 2 1,633 $275,000 $168 16 days
124 Rory Drive 3 2 1,801 $297,995 $165 18 days
1325 S Noble Street 3 2 1,248 $229,900 $184 20 days
321 W Mechanic Street 2 1 1,709 $165,000 $96 21 days
125 Rolling Ridge Road 3 2 1,264 $225,000 $178 22 days
5399 E Range Road 5 3 2,740 $479,900 $175 26 days
2725 N Richard Drive 4 3 2,660 $349,000 $131 28 days
875 W Highland Drive 2 2 1,410 $204,900 $145 29 days
103 Western Trace 3 3 2,210 $494,900 $223 32 days
332 W Taylor Street 1 1 645 $45,000 $69 39 days
2124 Poncianni Avenue 3 2 1,156 $144,900 $125 41 days
424 Lockerbie Road 4 3 2,864 $324,900 $113 42 days
7891 E Blue Ridge Road 3 1 2,148 $243,000 $113 44 days
514 Wellington Boulevard 3 2 1,275 $199,000 $156 46 days
902 Olmsted Court 4 3 2,850 $274,900 $96 49 days
1713 Senior Court 2 2 1,539 $234,900 $152 50 days
1988 Oak Terrace Drive 4 2 1,601 $274,999 $171 50 days
407 Eberhart Drive 3 1 984 $205,000 $208 51 days
953 Balto Drive 3 3 1,704 $208,000 $122 53 days
1395 Aster Drive 4 2 1,771 $297,805 $168 59 days
1420 Honeysuckle Drive 5 3 2,600 $309,900 $119 71 days
326 W Taylor Street 2 1 1,158 $138,900 $119 71 days
53 W Pennsylvania Street 3 1 1,198 $152,500 $127 75 days
2806 Theobald Street 3 2 2,078 $301,900 $145 77 days
1580 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $326,900 $139 84 days
2329 Bear Oak Run 3 2 1,520 $264,990 $174 85 days
916 Belvedere Drive 4 3 2,060 $224,900 $109 87 days
2496 Turf Way 3 3 3,253 $434,900 $133 88 days
3465 W Smithland Freedom Street 3 2 1,496 $249,950 $167 99 days
525 W Mechanic Street 2 1 2,016 $199,000 $98 108 days
2024 Oak Terrace Drive 3 2 1,350 $239,999 $177 113 days
2032 Oak Terrace Drive 3 3 1,594 $259,999 $163 113 days
1225 E Hazelwood Street S 4 2 1,656 $175,000 $105 135 days
2317 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,169 $279,990 $129 135 days
818 Moriseni Avenue 3 2 1,440 $147,000 $102 150 days
2318 Marjorie Way 3 2 1,460 $267,990 $183 151 days
1515 Canterbury Drive 3 2 2,117 $225,000 $106 160 days
109 Walker Street 3 3 1,628 $185,000 $113 165 days
1560 Aster Drive 3 2 1,272 $239,900 $188 197 days
1120 Central Park Drive 4 3 3,202 $237,000 $74 227 days
2415 Derby Drive 5 3 3,220 $399,900 $124 239 days
Average: 3.2 2.2 1,894 $253,244 $140 79 days
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1655 Carriage Circle 3 3 2,312 $250,000 $240,000 $103 51 days 9/11/26
2325 Steeple Chase 2 2 1,304 $219,500 $210,000 $161 106 days 9/9/26
1202 Sycamore Drive 2 2 1,577 $225,000 $225,000 $142 24 days 9/4/26
1018 S West Street 2 2 2,287 $220,000 $220,150 $96 49 days 9/2/26
111 3rd Street 3 1 2,496 $194,900 $193,000 $77 0 days 9/1/26
116 N Vine Street 2 1 976 $15,000 $22,500 $23 17 days 9/1/26
304 Foxridge Court 3 2 1,353 $260,000 $256,500 $189 42 days 8/29/26
111 Foxborough Run 4 3 3,537 $539,500 $540,000 $152 89 days 8/28/26
1310 E 225 S 3 1 976 $215,000 $215,000 $220 21 days 8/26/26
819 Highpointe Boulevard 6 3 3,696 $242,000 $210,000 $56 34 days 8/26/26
1368 Bontrager Lane 5 3 4,994 $395,000 $405,000 $81 3 days 8/25/26
701 Eberhart Drive 3 1 864 $187,000 $196,000 $226 32 days 8/25/26
2143 Bear Oak Run 3 3 1,797 $269,999 $257,000 $143 95 days 8/25/26
2785 N Fleming Circle 3 3 1,530 $250,000 $205,000 $133 102 days 8/25/26
175 Isabelle Lane 4 3 2,347 $304,995 $298,000 $126 105 days 8/21/26
181 Isabelle Lane 4 3 2,191 $299,995 $299,995 $136 103 days 8/19/26
939 Olmsted Court 4 3 1,846 $235,000 $240,000 $130 110 days 8/19/26
902 W Highland Drive 3 2 1,827 $260,000 $260,000 $142 40 days 8/17/26
1056 Balto Drive 4 3 2,596 $272,900 $272,900 $105 45 days 8/14/26
862 Saraina Road 2 2 1,110 $212,500 $212,500 $191 52 days 8/14/26
111 Fairfield Drive 2 2 1,736 $199,000 $160,000 $92 57 days 8/14/26
4568 N State Road 9 2 2 2,083 $469,900 $455,000 $218 92 days 8/14/26
2620 N Richard Drive 4 3 2,807 $339,000 $305,000 $108 93 days 8/14/26
225 E Pennsylvania Street 3 1 2,334 $120,000 $113,450 $48 123 days 8/14/26
1598 S Thompson Road 2 2 1,176 $260,000 $260,000 $221 99 days 8/13/26
2322 Marjorie Way 3 3 2,169 $299,990 $298,990 $137 107 days 8/12/26
2609 Berwick 3 2 1,633 $260,000 $260,000 $159 54 days 8/10/26
6485 W 100 S 4 3 3,041 $600,000 $570,000 $187 42 days 8/7/26
1009 Balto Drive 5 3 3,000 $274,900 $269,412 $89 49 days 8/7/26
449 E McKay Road 3 3 2,668 $429,900 $402,000 $150 57 days 8/7/26
2321 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,755 $349,990 $344,990 $125 49 days 8/6/26
2307 Eagle Brook Drive 3 2 1,631 $264,900 $270,000 $165 25 days 8/4/26
2016 S Riley 3 3 2,190 $255,000 $248,000 $113 49 days 7/31/26
511 Eberhart Drive 2 1 896 $174,900 $175,000 $195 88 days 7/31/26
1550 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $324,900 $321,600 $137 120 days 7/31/26
150 E Pennsylvania Street 3 2 1,526 $189,900 $185,900 $121 56 days 7/30/26
2311 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,308 $319,990 $319,990 $138 92 days 7/30/26
1787 W 250 S 2 2 1,100 $199,000 $194,000 $176 28 days 7/29/26
2336 Steeple Chase 2 2 1,496 $224,900 $225,000 $150 47 days 7/29/26
404 W Franklin Street 3 1 2,550 $160,000 $155,000 $60 62 days 7/29/26
116 E Pennsylvania Street 3 3 1,336 $180,000 $180,000 $134 105 days 7/29/26
706 8th Street 3 1 2,134 $175,000 $190,000 $89 34 days 7/28/26
3730 N State Road 9 3 2 1,384 $279,000 $270,000 $195 34 days 7/27/26
426 S 600 W 3 3 1,960 $325,000 $325,500 $166 36 days 7/27/26
2827 S Oakland Drive 5 2 2,788 $230,000 $180,000 $64 70 days 7/27/26
3643 W 600 S 5 3 3,186 $345,000 $317,000 $99 109 days 7/27/26
1511 Rolling Ridge Road 3 2 1,801 $305,528 $305,528 $169 140 days 7/24/26
1535 Rolling Ridge Road 3 2 1,228 $243,336 $243,336 $198 149 days 7/24/26
20 W Locust Street 3 2 2,763 $210,000 $214,000 $77 30 days 7/24/26
416 Montgomery Street 4 2 1,680 $139,900 $120,000 $71 77 days 7/24/26
Average: 3.2 2.2 1,965 $255,660 $251,573 $137 85 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 210
Viewing 1 - 50 of 210

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative