Sign up to stay up to date on the Shelbyville, IN Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
823 Center Street 3 2 1,640 $239,900 $146 2 days
819 Highpointe Boulevard 6 3 3,696 $242,000 $65 4 days
902 Olmsted Court 4 3 2,850 $274,900 $96 3 days
701 Eberhart Drive 3 1 864 $187,000 $216 3 days
1713 Senior Court 2 2 1,539 $234,900 $152 4 days
2339 William Garrett Way 3 2 1,594 $284,990 $178 7 days
3878 E State Road 44 4 4 6,453 $824,900 $127 3 days
1988 Oak Terrace Drive 4 2 1,601 $274,999 $171 4 days
1655 Carriage Circle 3 3 2,312 $250,000 $108 5 days
1643 Senior Court 2 2 1,351 $259,900 $192 6 days
407 Eberhart Drive 3 1 1,250 $205,000 $164 5 days
734 Center Street 3 2 1,437 $240,000 $167 7 days
609 Montgomery Street 3 1 1,390 $139,900 $100 6 days
2051 Black Oak Drive 4 3 1,958 $279,999 $143 6 days
1163 Aster Drive 4 3 2,466 $332,900 $134 6 days
2039 Black Oak Drive 4 3 2,119 $289,999 $136 6 days
953 Balto Drive 3 3 1,704 $228,000 $133 7 days
2325 Steeple Chase 2 2 1,304 $224,900 $172 62 days
236 E Pennsylvania 4 2 2,010 $164,900 $82 7 days
1440 Wilmington Boulevard 3 2 1,426 $259,000 $181 9 days
304 Foxridge Court 3 2 1,353 $260,000 $192 9 days
710 Miller Avenue 4 2 3,153 $99,900 $31 10 days
1351 Aster Drive 3 2 1,498 $290,492 $193 13 days
1210 Ruby Drive 2 2 1,563 $237,000 $151 16 days
1327 S Harrison Street 2 1 1,476 $99,900 $67 20 days
2209 S Miller Avenue 3 2 1,355 $249,000 $183 18 days
1010 Stratford Lane 5 3 2,506 $319,000 $127 21 days
1317 Aster Drive 3 2 1,272 $259,558 $204 20 days
1333 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $338,600 $144 20 days
1420 Honeysuckle Drive 5 3 2,600 $325,000 $125 25 days
223 N Knightstown Road 2 1 1,088 $114,900 $105 23 days
106 4th Street 2 1 1,680 $149,900 $89 23 days
326 W Taylor Street 2 1 1,158 $139,900 $120 25 days
1018 Stratford Lane 3 3 1,664 $260,990 $156 28 days
4122 N 500 E 4 3 4,362 $785,000 $179 28 days
53 W Pennsylvania Street 3 1 1,198 $170,000 $141 29 days
2806 Theobald Street 3 2 2,078 $301,900 $145 31 days
4150 W 600 S 3 1 864 $200,000 $231 34 days
1624 Wagner Drive 3 3 1,872 $234,900 $125 53 days
Lot 135 911 Hale Road 3 2 1,456 $89,900 $61 38 days
1379 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $331,422 $141 38 days
1580 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $327,668 $139 38 days
2329 Bear Oak Run 3 2 1,520 $274,990 $180 39 days
111 Fairfield Drive 2 2 1,736 $210,000 $120 39 days
219 W Locust N/A N/A N/A $138,000 Unknown 40 days
916 Belvedere Drive 4 3 2,060 $234,900 $114 41 days
1854 Twelve Oaks Drive 4 3 2,871 $323,999 $112 46 days
2513 W 300 S 4 3 2,748 $460,000 $167 76 days
2392 Steeple Chase 3 2 1,442 $230,000 $159 46 days
438 Colescott Street 3 2 1,486 $155,900 $104 47 days
Average: 3.3 2.4 2,113 $285,892 $141 79 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 94
Viewing 1 - 50 of 94
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1018 S West Street 2 2 2,287 $220,000 $96 12 days
1395 Aster Drive 4 2 1,771 $297,805 $168 13 days
432 Lockerbie Road 3 1 1,299 $220,000 $169 17 days
2307 Eagle Brook Drive 3 2 1,631 $264,900 $162 17 days
1219 E McKay Road 3 2 1,513 $249,900 $165 19 days
902 W Highland Drive 3 2 1,827 $260,000 $142 19 days
1056 Balto Drive 4 3 2,596 $272,900 $105 27 days
1787 W 250 S 2 2 1,100 $199,000 $180 26 days
6485 W 100 S 4 3 3,041 $600,000 $197 31 days
1402 S Thompson Road 3 2 1,424 $239,900 $168 33 days
706 8th Street 3 1 2,134 $175,000 $82 33 days
20 W Locust Street 3 2 2,763 $210,000 $76 33 days
3730 N State Road 9 3 2 1,384 $279,000 $201 34 days
862 Saraina Road 2 2 1,110 $212,500 $191 34 days
426 S 600 W 3 3 1,960 $325,000 $165 36 days
1009 Balto Drive 5 3 3,000 $274,900 $91 38 days
2321 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,755 $349,990 $127 39 days
2609 Berwick 3 2 1,633 $260,000 $159 40 days
2496 Turf Way 3 3 3,253 $434,900 $133 42 days
2016 S Riley 3 3 2,190 $255,000 $116 45 days
2336 Steeple Chase 2 2 1,496 $224,900 $150 45 days
449 E McKay Road 3 3 2,668 $429,900 $161 46 days
150 E Pennsylvania Street 3 2 1,526 $189,900 $124 53 days
111 Foxborough Run 4 3 3,537 $539,500 $152 57 days
404 W Franklin Street 3 1 2,550 $160,000 $62 60 days
525 W Mechanic Street 2 1 2,016 $205,000 $101 62 days
2143 Bear Oak Run 3 3 1,797 $269,999 $150 66 days
2827 S Oakland Drive 5 2 2,788 $230,000 $82 70 days
2785 N Fleming Circle 3 3 1,530 $250,000 $163 73 days
4568 N State Road 9 2 2 2,083 $469,900 $225 74 days
2620 N Richard Drive 4 3 2,807 $339,000 $120 75 days
181 Isabelle Lane 4 3 2,191 $299,995 $136 80 days
175 Isabelle Lane 4 3 2,347 $304,995 $129 80 days
1598 S Thompson Road 2 2 1,176 $260,000 $221 82 days
511 Eberhart Drive 2 1 896 $174,900 $195 84 days
939 Olmsted Court 4 3 1,846 $235,000 $127 87 days
2311 Bear Oak Run 3 3 2,308 $319,990 $138 89 days
2322 Marjorie Way 3 3 2,169 $299,990 $138 91 days
116 E Pennsylvania Street 3 3 1,336 $180,000 $134 103 days
225 E Pennsylvania Street 3 1 2,334 $120,000 $51 105 days
336 W Broadway Street 4 2 5,488 $299,500 $54 105 days
328-330 W Mechanic Street N/A N/A N/A $79,000 Unknown 108 days
3643 W 600 S 5 3 3,186 $345,000 $108 109 days
204 E Pennsylvania Street 4 2 2,472 $99,500 $40 110 days
1550 Aster Drive 4 3 2,346 $324,900 $138 116 days
117 N Hamilton Street 3 3 1,488 $185,000 $124 129 days
1560 Aster Drive 3 2 1,272 $249,900 $196 151 days
1120 Central Park Drive 4 3 4,993 $237,000 $47 181 days
Average: 3.2 2.3 2,198 $269,238 $135 64 days
Viewing 1 - 48 of 48
Viewing 1 - 48 of 48
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
416 Montgomery Street 4 2 1,680 $139,900 $120,000 $71 77 days 7/24/26
325 Wellington Boulevard 2 1 720 $172,900 $172,900 $240 35 days 7/23/26
1224 Aster Way 5 3 2,600 $365,050 $365,050 $140 148 days 7/23/26
1974 N Knightstown Road 2 1 1,658 $149,900 $155,000 $93 33 days 7/22/26
2590 S Smithland Road 3 2 1,411 $239,900 $244,000 $172 85 days 7/22/26
168 W Broadway Street 5 2 2,770 $264,900 $235,000 $84 131 days 7/22/26
2023 Red Oak Court 3 2 1,530 $239,900 $229,900 $150 52 days 7/21/26
1301 State Street 1 1 822 $124,000 $119,000 $144 89 days 7/20/26
880 S Tompkins Street S 3 2 1,494 $199,500 $202,500 $135 29 days 7/17/26
1265 Shaw Lane 5 3 3,131 $404,900 $400,000 $127 108 days 7/17/26
2183 S Fairview Drive 4 2 1,404 $264,900 $264,900 $188 132 days 7/17/26
114 Western Trace 4 3 3,548 $449,000 $432,000 $121 69 days 7/15/26
570 Plowman Drive 5 3 2,506 $295,870 $298,190 $118 83 days 7/15/26
2216 Cherrybark Court 5 2 3,145 $289,900 $285,000 $90 74 days 7/14/26
211 Rory 3 2 1,613 $267,619 $267,619 $165 135 days 7/13/26
2305 Premier Street 3 2 1,600 $150,000 $148,000 $92 23 days 7/10/26
543 4th Street 3 1 2,220 $179,900 $176,000 $79 41 days 7/10/26
1212 Bontrager Lane 3 2 1,406 $290,000 $285,000 $202 99 days 7/10/26
2296 Marjorie Way 3 3 2,293 $294,990 $294,990 $128 245 days 7/6/26
901 Revello Street 3 1 888 $167,600 $167,600 $188 33 days 7/3/26
2836 N Michigan Road 3 1 1,116 $250,000 $237,000 $212 94 days 7/2/26
1004 Balto Drive 4 3 2,898 $289,900 $295,000 $101 46 days 6/30/26
1304 Ellington Drive 3 3 2,328 $249,900 $248,000 $106 64 days 6/30/26
2307 Saddle Drive 3 3 2,305 $389,900 $380,000 $164 67 days 6/30/26
154 W Hendricks Street 3 3 2,803 $244,900 $244,900 $87 89 days 6/30/26
729 E Washington Street 2 2 1,200 $114,900 $115,000 $95 97 days 6/30/26
1947 White Oak Lane 3 3 1,797 $264,999 $264,999 $147 133 days 6/30/26
953 W McKay Road 2 1 952 $99,000 $87,000 $91 136 days 6/30/26
5241 W Marietta Railroad Street 2 1 1,102 $183,000 $183,000 $166 97 days 6/29/26
2332 Marjorie Way 4 3 2,755 $336,990 $335,990 $121 58 days 6/26/26
1611 Carriage Circle 3 3 1,614 $230,000 $227,500 $140 29 days 6/25/26
1519 Counselor Row 3 2 1,216 $229,900 $235,000 $193 52 days 6/25/26
33 W Mechanic Street 2 1 2,383 $194,000 $190,000 $79 50 days 6/25/26
1007 Belvedere Drive 3 3 2,381 $279,000 $280,000 $117 98 days 6/25/26
2740 E 250 S 3 2 1,268 $254,500 $240,000 $189 106 days 6/25/26
606 W 450 S 3 1 910 $130,000 $120,000 $131 154 days 6/24/26
1407 Aster Drive 5 3 2,600 $315,900 $317,425 $122 82 days 6/23/26
920 Belvedere Drive 3 2 1,992 $229,900 $238,000 $119 60 days 6/22/26
2309 Eagle Brook Drive 3 2 1,257 $254,900 $255,000 $202 46 days 6/22/26
4557 S State Road 9 4 2 2,776 $239,900 $235,000 $84 55 days 6/22/26
1033 Balto Drive 4 3 2,800 $279,900 $270,000 $96 58 days 6/18/26
1216 Elm Street 2 1 2,736 $199,900 $190,000 $69 157 days 6/18/26
4097 N 200 E 4 3 3,756 $698,000 $726,500 $193 41 days 6/17/26
822 Berkeley 3 1 1,164 $127,000 $127,000 $109 1 day 6/16/26
1411 Valdosta Court 3 2 1,505 $260,000 $260,000 $172 49 days 6/16/26
904 Hemlock Street 3 2 1,160 $219,900 $217,000 $187 28 days 6/15/26
1007 S Miller Street 3 1 2,075 $190,000 $190,000 $91 34 days 6/15/26
915 Oak Park Drive 3 2 1,818 $289,900 $282,500 $155 41 days 6/15/26
1045 Swinford Street 4 3 1,918 $335,000 $340,000 $177 174 days 6/15/26
925 Balto Drive 3 3 1,792 $235,900 $235,900 $131 36 days 6/12/26
Average: 3.2 2.1 1,941 $251,029 $247,138 $136 92 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 204
Viewing 1 - 50 of 204

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative