Sign up to stay up to date on the Sheridan, IN Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1012 Maple Run Drive 3 3 2,016 $305,900 $151 3 days
19356 Atwater Avenue 2 2 1,632 $352,652 $216 3 days
551 Alder Way 4 3 2,463 $379,900 $154 6 days
607 S Sheridan Avenue 2 1 936 $190,000 $202 6 days
19513 Atwater Avenue 3 2 1,615 $338,425 $209 8 days
0 (10 acres) Jerkwater Road 5 4 4,199 $980,620 $233 11 days
0 (8 acres) Jerkwater Road 4 4 4,420 $970,905 $219 11 days
24479 Godby Street 4 2 1,771 $333,900 $188 10 days
3383 Stafford Street 5 3 2,904 $398,300 $137 10 days
1228 Maple Trace Way 4 3 3,344 $334,900 $100 14 days
553 Alder Way 4 3 2,484 $389,900 $156 19 days
1404 Graybark Street 3 2 1,437 $285,000 $198 25 days
24456 Godby Street 3 2 1,601 $333,900 $208 25 days
1450 Silver Pine Lane 4 3 2,466 $355,000 $143 26 days
603 W 216th Street 4 3 3,012 $1,600,000 $531 32 days
311 Shadetree Lane 4 3 2,046 $299,900 $146 40 days
24432 Godby Street 5 3 2,904 $389,900 $134 40 days
527 Buckthorn 5 3 3,243 $385,000 $118 47 days
22006 Oak Ridge 4 3 2,634 $3,360,600 $1,275 52 days
21080 Six Points Road 4 3 3,264 $820,000 $251 74 days
19397 Astoria Avenue 2 2 1,465 $315,000 $215 94 days
24443 Godby Street 3 2 1,503 $314,900 $209 96 days
1364 Folsome Avenue 3 2 2,182 $494,149 $226 118 days
10791 E State Road 47 4 4 4,506 $1,180,000 $261 266 days
511 Tomahawk Street 3 3 2,179 $299,900 $137 355 days
514 E 2nd Street 3 2 2,688 $275,000 $102 391 days
789 E State Road 38 4 4 3,010 $700,000 $232 1113 days
Average: 3.6 2.7 2,515 $606,801 $235 107 days
Viewing 1 - 27 of 27
Viewing 1 - 27 of 27
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
509 E 8th Street 3 1 1,184 $200,000 $168 10 days
212 Cross Bow Street 3 3 1,818 $270,000 $148 11 days
19583 Finley Creek Drive 5 4 4,924 $725,000 $147 17 days
25996 Six Points Road 4 2 2,520 $599,000 $237 22 days
1751 W 261st Street 5 2 2,520 $289,900 $115 25 days
21730 Oak Ridge 3 2 1,932 $525,000 $271 25 days
19368 Finley Creek Drive 5 5 4,948 $745,000 $150 28 days
28 Homestead Drive 3 2 2,840 $449,900 $158 32 days
505 E 1st Street 2 1 976 $199,000 $203 32 days
24467 Godby Street 5 3 2,600 $368,900 $141 39 days
506 S California Street 2 1 1,008 $75,000 $74 45 days
1410 Bigleaf Circle 3 2 1,477 $285,000 $192 46 days
1417 Graybark 3 3 2,440 $329,000 $134 47 days
406 Warrior Court 3 1 1,260 $245,000 $194 56 days
1484 Littleleaf Drive 3 2 1,618 $295,500 $182 72 days
19588 Astoria Avenue 3 2 1,785 $299,900 $168 77 days
24449 Godby Street 4 2 1,771 $329,900 $186 96 days
24431 Godby Street 4 2 1,771 $329,900 $186 96 days
307 N Blake Street 3 2 1,350 $274,900 $203 108 days
508 Buckthorn Lane 4 3 2,129 $324,900 $152 109 days
11315 E 300 N 3 2 3,352 $1,475,000 $440 122 days
19377 Astoria Avenue 2 2 1,532 $332,862 $217 202 days
19773 Highclere Lane 3 2 1,776 $382,136 $215 228 days
1353 Mahoning Road 4 3 2,496 $463,280 $185 231 days
19855 Freemont Moore (residential) Road 3 2 1,350 $975,000 $722 395 days
Average: 3.4 2.2 2,135 $431,559 $208 87 days
Viewing 1 - 25 of 25
Viewing 1 - 25 of 25
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
11410 E 300 N 5 5 6,701 $1,850,000 $1,800,000 $268 49 days 7/24/26
24473 Godby Street 3 2 1,503 $309,900 $309,900 $206 92 days 7/24/26
1469 Bigleaf Drive 4 3 2,243 $319,000 $319,000 $142 90 days 7/17/26
19418 Atwater Avenue 3 2 1,632 $341,659 $337,000 $206 108 days 7/17/26
503 Tomahawk Street 4 2 2,352 $299,900 $296,000 $125 38 days 7/13/26
19785 Highclere Lane 2 2 1,776 $387,485 $375,000 $211 182 days 7/13/26
103 Elm Avenue 3 2 2,168 $299,900 $299,000 $137 80 days 7/10/26
780 W 236th Street 4 2 3,172 $425,000 $405,000 $127 42 days 7/9/26
520 W 4th Street 3 2 1,792 $295,000 $295,000 $164 53 days 7/9/26
1246 Folsome Avenue 2 2 1,776 $388,199 $378,000 $212 65 days 7/7/26
19488 Atwater 2 2 1,615 $332,862 $332,862 $206 98 days 7/2/26
38 Homestead Drive 3 2 2,200 $347,900 $336,000 $152 146 days 7/1/26
1134 Maple Trace Way 3 3 2,164 $299,999 $300,000 $138 239 days 7/1/26
1425 Bigleaf Drive 4 3 2,256 $335,000 $335,000 $148 47 days 6/30/26
1423 Bigleaf Drive 3 2 1,825 $315,000 $300,000 $164 43 days 6/26/26
548 Yellowleaf Drive 3 2 1,921 $345,719 $344,933 $179 211 days 6/18/26
7116 S County Road 1400 E 3 1 2,098 $335,000 $317,000 $151 45 days 6/18/26
1004 Maple Run Drive 3 2 1,399 $279,900 $275,000 $196 78 days 6/18/26
1478 Pine Bark Lane 3 2 1,618 $299,900 $302,000 $186 85 days 6/18/26
19653 Highclere Lane 2 2 1,772 $375,000 $375,000 $211 49 days 6/16/26
1119 E 234th Street 3 3 2,054 $415,000 $415,000 $202 31 days 6/15/26
24510 Godby Street 5 3 2,600 $359,900 $359,900 $138 101 days 6/15/26
1012 Park Place 2 2 1,181 $250,000 $250,000 $211 29 days 6/12/26
100 S Blake Street 3 1 896 $192,500 $198,000 $220 58 days 6/12/26
1107 S Opel Avenue 3 2 1,494 $129,900 $115,000 $76 13 days 6/11/26
1115 Maple Run Drive 5 3 3,592 $379,900 $379,900 $105 32 days 6/10/26
10719 E State Road 38 2 1 2,534 $289,000 $269,000 $106 98 days 6/10/26
19749 Highclere Lane 2 2 1,776 $372,629 $367,000 $206 188 days 6/3/26
509 1/2 E 1st Street 3 2 1,318 $225,000 $230,000 $174 73 days 6/1/26
24486 Godby Street 4 2 1,771 $334,595 $331,095 $186 84 days 5/29/26
1123 Maple Run Drive 3 2 1,887 $297,500 $297,500 $157 55 days 5/28/26
19824 Atwater Avenue 4 3 2,468 $454,000 $452,000 $183 330 days 5/28/26
24516 Godby Street 4 3 2,600 $357,400 $357,400 $137 130 days 5/20/26
19416 Atwater 3 2 1,632 $341,608 $329,000 $201 54 days 5/20/26
202 S Linden Lane 3 2 1,642 $250,000 $260,000 $158 33 days 5/19/26
19537 Atwater Avenue 2 2 1,615 $337,618 $335,000 $207 55 days 5/19/26
21749 Oak Ridge Road 4 3 2,000 $2,000,000 $2,150,000 $1,075 365 days 5/19/26
1453 Silver Pine Lane 3 2 1,825 $314,900 $314,900 $172 32 days 5/18/26
19647 Jaipur Way 5 3 3,300 $506,436 $506,436 $153 56 days 5/18/26
24500 Jerkwater Road 4 3 5,066 $385,000 $383,500 $75 195 days 5/18/26
1450 Bigleaf Drive 3 2 1,817 $325,000 $330,000 $181 38 days 5/15/26
606 W 2nd Street 2 1 1,063 $192,500 $192,500 $181 74 days 5/15/26
8410 N Washington Street 3 1 1,894 $214,950 $215,000 $113 112 days 5/15/26
1479 Mahoning Road 4 3 2,496 $460,763 $460,763 $184 51 days 5/14/26
1483 Hardwood Drive 3 2 1,613 $305,634 $305,634 $189 170 days 5/13/26
19515 Atwater Avenue 2 2 1,515 $330,000 $330,000 $217 33 days 5/11/26
700 W 2nd Street W 2 2 1,296 $228,000 $205,000 $158 149 days 5/8/26
19542 Atwater Avenue 2 2 1,615 $330,419 $330,419 $204 112 days 5/4/26
202-204 E 11th Street N/A N/A N/A $355,000 $355,000 Unknown 35 days 5/1/26
8327 N Washington Street 2 1 2,352 $175,000 $152,200 $64 35 days 5/1/26
Average: 3.3 2.3 2,183 $395,286 $390,888 $183 90 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 85
Viewing 1 - 50 of 85

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative