Where Can You Get Ice Cream and Dessert in Westfield, Indiana?

Westfield has two main ice cream stops right now. Graeter's Ice Cream on East Tournament Trail opened on June 10, 2026, with a drive-thru and patio, and Big Hoffa's Freezery on East Main Street runs an ice cream counter inside Big Hoffa's Smokehouse BBQ, known for its oversized Insane Shakes.

Graeter's Ice Cream

Graeter's, at 391 E. Tournament Trail, opened June 10, 2026. The drive-thru makes it an easy stop after a game at Grand Park, and the patio works for a sit-down treat.

Big Hoffa's Freezery

Big Hoffa's Freezery, at 800 E. Main St., operates inside Big Hoffa's Smokehouse BBQ. It is best known for its Insane Shakes. Call ahead to confirm the counter is open before a special trip.

A Note on Closed Shops

Some older roundups still list Cone + Crumb, which closed permanently in January 2024. If you see it in a search, it is no longer an option.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Graeter's open in Westfield, Indiana?
Graeter's Ice Cream opened at 391 E. Tournament Trail in Westfield on June 10, 2026.

Does the Westfield Graeter's have a drive-thru?
Yes. The Westfield Graeter's has a drive-thru and an outdoor patio.

What are Insane Shakes in Westfield?
Insane Shakes are the oversized milkshakes served at Big Hoffa's Freezery, inside Big Hoffa's Smokehouse BBQ at 800 E. Main St.

Is Cone + Crumb in Westfield still open?
No. Cone + Crumb closed permanently in January 2024.

More local guides: Best Bakeries and Donut Shops in Westfield, Best BBQ Restaurants in Westfield, Weekend Activities for Families, Moving to Westfield, IN, the Hamilton County, IN Real Estate hub, and Jason Kraus, Top Realtor in Westfield, IN.

Thinking About a Move in Hamilton County?

Whether you are buying, selling, or just getting to know the area, reach out to the MOVE Group at 317-714-9580 for a no-obligation conversation about your next move.

Jason Kraus, Broker/Owner, REMAX Advanced Realty. MOVE Group at REMAX Advanced Realty, headquartered in Westfield, Indiana.