Westfield's best-rated Italian restaurants are The Italian House on Park (4.5 stars, upscale-casual) and Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar (4.7 stars, chef-driven pasta and seafood), with Jan's Village Pizza and Greek's Pizzeria of Westfield covering the more casual, family-friendly end of the spectrum.
For a date night or special occasion
The Italian House on Park is Westfield's highest-volume-reviewed Italian spot, sitting at 4.5 stars across 183 Tripadvisor reviews, and it leans upscale-casual — the kind of place that works for a date night but still welcomes kids. Diners consistently mention the comfortable dining room and attentive service.
Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar, at 3150 East IN-32, rates even higher at 4.7 stars (44 reviews) and focuses on handcrafted pasta, fresh seafood, and traditional antipasti — think spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, chicken gorgonzola, shrimp and risotto, and linguine with clams, plus vegan options and a full bar. It's open for dinner Tuesday through Sunday (closed Mondays) and takes reservations.
For a casual, kid-friendly pizza night
If you want pizza without the fuss, Jan's Village Pizza is a locally-owned spot known for being affordable and easy with kids — it even has a $5.99 kids' spaghetti option on the menu. Greek's Pizzeria of Westfield is another family-friendly option in the same casual category, with high chairs on hand and a solid kids' menu. Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub rounds out the casual Italian/pizza category with online ordering for a quick weeknight dinner.
The bottom line
Westfield doesn't have a huge number of dedicated Italian restaurants, but what's here covers the full range — from a genuine date-night option in Pasto Italiano, to an upscale-but-still-casual standby in The Italian House, down to reliably kid-friendly pizza nights at Jan's Village and Greek's Pizzeria.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the highest-rated Italian restaurant in Westfield, Indiana?
Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar rates 4.7 stars on Tripadvisor, the highest among Westfield's Italian restaurants, known for handcrafted pasta and fresh seafood.
Is there a good Italian restaurant in Westfield for a date night?
Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar and The Italian House on Park are both considered Westfield's go-to options for a date night or special occasion, with full bars and reservations available.
Where can I get kid-friendly Italian food or pizza in Westfield?
Jan's Village Pizza and Greek's Pizzeria of Westfield are both known locally as easy, affordable, kid-friendly options, with Jan's offering a $5.99 kids' spaghetti dish.
Does Pasto Italiano take reservations?
Yes, Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar takes reservations and is open for dinner Tuesday through Sunday, closed Mondays.
Looking for a home near Westfield's restaurant scene? I can send you listings close to town center and walk you through what's nearby. Let me know a good time to talk.
Jason Kraus, Broker/Owner, REMAX Advanced Realty — MOVE Group, Hamilton County's dedicated local team headquartered in Westfield.
Note: please confirm current hours for Pasto Italiano before this stays live long-term, since restaurant hours can shift seasonally.
