Masthead, Fishers, IN Real Estate | Masthead, Fishers, IN Recently Sold Homes

This exceptional waterfront retreat on Geist Reservoir, located in sought-after HSE Schools, is perfectly positioned on a spectacular .7-acre wooded cul-de-sac lot. This home offers a rare 235 feet of private water frontage, complete with a wraparound boardwalk, boat dock, lift, and canopy-designed for effortless lake living. Outdoor spaces shine with a vaulted screened in porch, multiple composite decks plus two paver patios. This level backyard is ideal for entertaining or unwinding lakeside. Inside, tall ceilings and walls of windows capture stunning water views from 3 sides of the home, while custom millwork and special design features elevate every space. The main-level Owner's Retreat is a true sanctuary, featuring a beautiful ensuite bath with a tile shower and soaking tub, heated tile floors and private access to the rear deck, where peaceful water views greet you each morning. A flexible main-level guest suite or home office adds convenience and versatility. The kitchen is a standout with a Viking range and Sub-Zero refrigerator, opening seamlessly to a cozy hearth room anchored by one of two fireplaces and direct access to the vaulted screened porch. The recently remodeled walk-out lower level is built for entertaining, offering a wet bar, recreation space, spacious exercise room and full bath. Upstairs you will enjoy 3 additional bedrooms, one with a private ensuite bath and a jack-and-jill with dual sinks between the others. This is more than a home-it's a lifestyle. A rare Geist waterfront opportunity that truly must be experienced in person.

9806 Gulfstream Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®. Selling Office: eXp Realty LLC.

$1,083,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Masthead Waterfront Paradise - Where Every Day Feels Like a Getaway. Wake up to the shimmer of the reservoir right outside your window, coffee in hand, as the gentle call of waterfowl drifts through the morning air. Hard to find 139' of shoreline! This 4-bedroom, 3-bath treasure in the sought-after Masthead community turns that vision into your daily reality, with a main-floor primary suite, private home office, and an airy, light-filled floorplan that frames the water from the moment you step inside. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the breakfast room and living spaces, where walls of windows turn nature into your ever-changing backdrop. Step outside and the lifestyle expands-a Trex upper deck perfect for soaking in the morning sun, a shaded lower deck for lazy afternoons, and a screened-in porch spacious enough to gather friends and family for cozy, rainy-day conversations. From the walk-out basement, follow the path to your backyard retreat, where a bubbling hot tub invites starlit soaks and a large deck at the water's edge sets the stage for dockside dinners, laughter-filled evenings, and sunset watching that never gets old. Life in this quiet cove offers the best of all four seasons-summer boating, sunrise paddleboarding, and kayaking right from your backyard; crisp autumn mornings with golden reflections on the water; and in winter, a sparkling wonderland perfect for skating. Whether you're entertaining a crowd or savoring peaceful moments alone, every day feels like a vacation here. Recent updates ensure comfort and peace of mind, including refinished wood floors (2024), a new shed and exterior paint (2019), HVAC system (2021), tankless water heater (2020), hot tub addition, sprinkler system (2022), engineered hardwood flooring in the lower level (2020), and more. An encapsulated crawl space with dehumidifier, epoxied garage floors, and lush landscaping complete this exceptional lakefront offering.

11712 Armada Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: MIBOR REALTOR® Association.

$570,500

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

LOOKING FOR A HOME WITH A DEEDED BOAT DOCK ON GEIST? Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a stunning 3-bedroom, 3 and 1/2 bath all-brick home with a basement, complete with a nearby deeded dock, motorized solar lift, and canopy. This home features a beautifully flowing floor plan that seamlessly connects all the bedrooms to the family room, separate dining room, kitchen, breakfast room and laundry room. The finished basement is perfect for a home theater, recreation room, or playroom. The kitchen, updated in 2023, showcases quartz countertops and backsplash, soft close cabinets, a sunken sink, and stainless steel appliances. Hardwood floors flow throughout all bedrooms, complemented by newly installed tile, as well as updated light fixtures and window treatments. Enjoy modernized bathrooms equipped with new vanities, soft close cabinets and stylish hardware for a fresh look. In 2024, the Greatroom's fireplace was converted to a gas fireplace with an easy-to-use gas starter, adding warmth to the cozy two-story living room. The spacious master suite boasts a jetted garden tub, separate tile shower, dual vanities, and a tray ceiling. Most mechanicals have been recently updated, including a water heater, sump pump, and garbage disposal installed in 2023, as well as a new dishwasher and microwave added this year. The roof, furnace, and AC were replaced in 2019, while the windows and composite deck were updated in 2018. Abundant with natural light, this home features multiple windows and skylights. The gorgeous backyard spans nearly 1/2 acre surrounded by mature trees. The boat dock is conveneintly located off Fall Creek Rd and has a seperate dock association fee of $200 per year.

10160 Sea Star Way, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$370,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

This charming ranch, nestled in the coveted Masthead Lake Community, was lovingly planned and has been cared for for the past 39 years. Your good fortune is that if you are looking for a one-owner, custom built home in a fantastic Fishers location, it's owner is is now accepting offers to fill its walls with joy yet again! Imagine relaxing evenings in the living room, where the high and vaulted ceilings create an expansive atmosphere, and the fireplace provides a warm and inviting focal point. The kitchen offers a backsplash, solid wood cabinetry, and stone countertops that combine style with functionality, making meal preparation a genuine pleasure. One of the bedrooms includes an ensuite bathroom, providing a private retreat within your own home. Indulge in the luxurious bathroom experience, featuring a double vanity, a walk-in shower, and a jetted tub, creating your own personal spa. Outside, the property offers a private pool, perfect for enjoying sunny days, alongside a patio and deck that provide ample space for outdoor dining and entertainment. The fenced backyard provides a secure area for relaxation and recreation. Additional features include a laundry room and a walk-in closet, adding convenience to everyday living. This 1851 square foot home on a generous .46 acre lot, offers a wonderful opportunity to embrace a comfortable and enjoyable lifestyle. Granted, it could use some color refreshes, but this beauty is open to a make over!

11662 Gulfstream Drive, Fishers

Listing courtesy of CKing Real Estate Services LLC. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$650,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to this very charming custom Nantucket style home with 4 Br's and 4 Baths. (2 full and 2 half baths). Original owners have created such beautiful curb appeal on this .52 acre tree lined private lot in Masthead. The back of the home has a lovely screened in porch and steps out to a spacious paver patio area with a built in firepit. The kitchen has been updated with a large quartz island, white cabinetry, kitchen aid appliances, electric oven and gas range. All kitchen appliances stay, all refrigerators, as well as the W+D. The home has a dining room and office area. There are 2 sets of stairs to the upper level. One right off the kitchen. Upstairs there are 4 nice size bedrooms, all bathrooms have been updated and their is a large bonus room currently being used as an exercise room. The lower level is finished where you will find a second fireplace, lots of space for fun and entertainment and room for storage. The 2 car garage comes with an access door. You are steps away from Geist Lake, restaurants and shopping.

10033 Sea Star Way, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home. Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$779,500

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Thoughtfully updated gorgeous ranch home, 5 large bedrooms & 3.5 baths, with a walkout basement, open airy floorplan, perfect for entertaining. Generous Chef's kitchen, large enough for gathering, casual dining, a drink bar, beautiful center island, upgraded stainless appliances, quartzite tops, hard wood floors. Laundry on the main floor, soaker sink, storage cabinets with organizers. Home is light bright cheerful. Expansive dining room, tray ceiling and will place in home for a large gathering or a cozy dinner. Great room with Frplc, built-in bookcases, lovely view into the heavy tree lined backyard gives the feel of living in the tress. You will love the privacy. Screened porch just off the kitchen opens out onto the good-sized deck. Primary bedroom boasts large walk-in closet and two additional closets, updated bathroom has radiant heated floors, large walk-in shower, separate tub, and a nice size too. All the bedrooms are of good size. Basement boast a second kitchen/wet bar, with new stainless applc's, quartz countertops, gas/wood burning fireplace with raise brick hearth, two true bedrooms, one bedroom is used as a playroom currently, full bath and a fairy room is finished under the stairwell so don't miss it.

11624 Horizon Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

$850,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Gorgeous home on Geist an amazing backyard oasis situated on a half acre lot with a 40x20 salt water pool, deeded dock with boat and jet ski lift, and an expansive deck with room to entertain the masses. You will love the updated kitchen with large island with sink and breakfast bar, high-end stainless appliances, and lots of storage. Spacious great room with dramatic ceiling, built-ins, fireplace, and doors that connect the living space with the outside. Formal dining room with 2nd fireplace and bonus/office room. Main floor primary suite features an updated spa-like bath with double sinks and walk-in closet. Upstairs are two generous bedrooms and a full bath. Storage shed and invisible fence stay. Enjoy lake life at it's best.

11733 Gulfstream Drive, Fishers

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: RE/MAX Realty Services.

$557,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to your dream home in Fishers in the highly sought-after Masthead neighborhood, just one block from Geist Lake in Hamilton Southeastern School District. This stunning custom brick home features four bedrooms and two and a half baths, offering a perfect blend of comfort and style. Step inside to discover a spacious two-story foyer and a large vaulted Great Room complete with skylights that fill the space with natural light. The floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace with gas logs creates an inviting atmosphere. The remodeled kitchen is a chef's delight, equipped with stainless steel appliances, an island and peninsula with bar seating, granite countertops, a tile backsplash, and a walk-in pantry. The breakfast room offers views of the amazing backyard and features a charming faux brick accent wall. A convenient fourth bedroom is located on the main level, complete with a built-in desk area. Enjoy outdoor living at its finest with a huge screened-in back porch that opens to a deck and a private wooded backyard, complete with raised garden beds perfect for gardening enthusiasts. The outdoor oasis strikes the perfect balance of grass and natural park-like settings, including your own private meditation garden & outdoor fire pit. The upstairs hosts a generously sized primary bedroom with an updated bathroom featuring double sinks, a private water closet, a large linen closet, a walk-in tiled shower, and a spacious walk-in closet. You'll also find two additional large bedrooms and a cozy loft area, along with the guest bathroom that features a new vanity with double sinks. Additional updates & features include a new roof and gutter guards (2022), new carpeting, refinished floors, and fresh interior painting, irrigation system, large laundry room with plenty of storage. Don't miss this opportunity to own a beautiful home in a prime location, close to Geist Lake, Sailing Club, Yacht Club, local restaurants, & entertainment!

11812 Gulfstream Drive, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: CrestPoint Real Estate.

$635,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Impressive Custom home situated on a large, private, wooded cul-de-sac lot in popular Masthead. In the past couple years this home has received loads of updates including the addition of a high-end custom Kitchen with quality appliances, built-in refrigerator and pantry, quartz counters and island, and beautiful butler pantry/bar area. Substantial custom millwork was added throughout the main floor. Open Two story Entry with great staircase. Family Room with new hardwood flooring, masonry fireplace, custom built-in bookcases and wall of windows. Open Living/Flex Room and separate Dining Room with new hardwood floors. Spacious Primary Suite with updated Bath, heated floors and large walk-in closet. Three additional Bedroom up with hardwood/laminate flooring and updated full Bath. Upstairs Laundry/Utility Room. Finished Lower Level with Theater Room area, a Billiards/Rec Room area, and daylight windows. Beautiful, spacious Screened Porch with cathedral ceiling and tile floors, large deck and water features. Oversized 2.5 car Garage. Family Room hanging light fixture excluded.

9946 Sea Star Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$672,500

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths

RARE OPPORTUNITY in MASTHEAD! Hard to Find MULTI GENERATION Home 6 BR/3Full BA and 2 1/2 Baths PLUS Office/Den! As you step inside you will be greeted by the warmth of this AMAZING Multi Gen home. UNBELIEVABLE main level In-Law qtrs/apt exudes opulence to the highest degree with a Living Rm/Kitchenette Combo and Luxurious tile shower and jetted bathtub plus double vanity sinks, Huge Walk-in Closet and Spacious Bedroom has separate entry overlooking tranquil backyard! Seeing is believing!!! The Heart of this Home is a Wonderful kitchen complete w/ granite countertops, SS appliances, 2 Breakfast bars and eating area open to family room PLUS...Formal dining room! Retreat to the Luxurious Owners suite upstairs, where comfort meets sophistication with Huge walk-in closet, spa like en-suite bath, offers the perfect escape! Four additional SPACIOUS bedrooms have ample walk-in closet storage and lifestyle flexibility! Wait....there's more... Finished Bsmnt for added living and enjoyment w/ 2 rec/play areas PLUS Wet Bar for entertaining during the Big Game AND 1/2 Bath! Completing this home is an Oversized 2+ car garage w/ HUGE driveway Pad can accommodate 4 CARS!!! Plus outside storage shed, Awesome rear deck overlooking lush backyard, great for relaxing on a quite evening or bird watching during the day! This meticulously maintained home offers the perfect blend of luxury, functionality and timeless appeal. You MUST SEE to BELIEVE this Rare Gem!!!

10151 Sea Star Way, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate. Selling Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$522,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to your dream home nestled on a tranquil cul-de-sac! This stunning residence greets you with a lovely front porch, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the neighborhood. Inside, you'll find 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and flexible spaces to suit your lifestyle needs. Upon entering you will discover soaring ceilings that create an airy and open ambiance, anchored by a magnificent double-sided fireplace that adds warmth and charm to both the living and dining areas. The main floor primary suite offers a private retreat with ample space and comfort. The heart of the home is the beautifully updated kitchen, complete with sleek quartz countertops, a center island, and modern appliances, making it a chef's delight. The versatile main floor office, complete with a closet, can easily be transformed into a nursery, den, or additional bedroom. Upstairs, a bonus space offers endless possibilities as an extra bedroom or a second living area, ensuring there's room for everyone. The expansive and fully fenced backyard features a large deck, perfect for outdoor entertaining, with ample room for a pool. Additional features include great storage options with a walk-up attic accessible through the oversized 3-car garage, offering plenty of space for vehicles and all your storage needs. This home perfectly combines elegance, functionality, and comfort, making it a perfect choice for your next move. Don't miss the opportunity to make this exceptional property your own!

10012 Bahamas Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$605,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Check out this gorgeous custom 4bd/2.5ba home with a basement! The curb appeal of this house is spectacular with beautiful landscaping and a dream front porch. As you enter, you're greeted with a 2 story foyer full of natural light. As you step through the home, you'll find hardwood floors, 9-ft ceilings, a first-floor office, laundry room, formal living room, and dining room. The updated kitchen features stainless steel appliances, so much cabinet space, an island, a breakfast nook, Cambria Quartz countertops, and a custom hood vent. The family room provides the perfect spot for entertaining right off the kitchen with a gas fireplace. Upstairs, you'll find a spacious primary suite with a tray ceiling, huge bathroom with double sinks, free-standing tub, custom shower with seat, walk-in closet, and storage area IN the closet! The three additional bedrooms provide ample space and the second bathroom features custom tile work. In the basement, you'll see a huge additional family room, perfect for entertaining! The other half provides so much room for storage. Head outside to enjoy the screened-in porch, the fire pit on the natural stone patio, or roam around the private backyard! Recent updates include new carpet (2024), 8 new windows (2024), new sump pump (2024), bathroom remodels including half bath (2022), new window shades (2023), kitchen remodel (2020), new exterior siding (2020), fresh interior and exterior paint! Located in a quiet neighborhood with 24/7 security AND just minutes from Geist Reservoir, the Hawthorns Golf and Country Club, and local shops and restaurants!

10137 Sea Star Way, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N. Selling Office: @properties.

$1,095,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Exceptional Geist waterfront living nestled on a wooded, walk-out cove homesite in sought-after HSE schools! Ideally situated with 105' of direct waterfront access, enjoy stunning water views & evening sunsets from both levels of this desirable & inviting ranch. Beautifully remodeled, this 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home includes more than $300,000 in extensive updates throughout. The gourmet kitchen features raised 10' ceilings, custom cabinetry & a center island, quartz & natural-finish artisan island top, induction cooktop & range hood, built-in stainless appliances & a beverage center. Wake up to water views in the spacious Owner's Retreat with tray ceiling, bay window sitting area & a fully remodeled spa-like bath with custom cabinetry, free-standing tub, and an expansive shower. Relax in the sunroom, enjoying year-round water views with windows on all sides. The Great Room is highlighted by a statement stone fireplace, custom built-ins & hand-scraped hardwoods. You will love the soaring ceilings & natural light! Generous & oversized bedrooms throughout, one main level bedroom includes double doors making it ideal for a private home office. Walk-out lower level offers direct access to the water, and is perfect for entertaining with a wet bar, living room & cozy stone fireplace, billiards & exercise rooms, and a private guest suite. Outside, a new composite deck with gas line & grill, and spacious walk-out patio with awning provide the perfect spots to enjoy the water and well-manicured landscaping. Expanded private dock area includes lift & canopy frame, and has room for 2 jet-ski docks. The finished garage features a keyless entry, a workshop area, service door, and access to overhead attic storage. You'll love this timeless blend of thoughtful updates & inviting charm. Don't miss the opportunity to make this waterfront retreat your own!

9816 Gulfstream Drive, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$389,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Looking for a custom built, one owner, 2 bedroom with a den/office in a great Fishers location --close to restaurants, shopping and Geist Reservoir? This home offers an open concept, 9' ceilings with all new flooring and interior paint. The great room is open to the dining room and kitchen that includes new quartz counter tops, sink, faucet, disposal, stove and refrigerator. Gorgeous brick fireplace is a focal point that warms up the kitchen, dining and great rooms. Add in a wall of windows that overlooks a private backyard. Two large bedrooms with walk in closets and updated bathroom vanities, lighting, mirrors, sinks and faucets. French doors open to an office that offers privacy and an additional space for reading, tv, hobbies or music room. Walk up attic storage that could be finished for additional space. No neighbors behind and located on a quiet cul-de-sac This isn't your cookie cutter home! Truly move in ready and waiting for your custom finishes.

10110 Bahamas Circle, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$549,300

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Stunning Geist home features 'Juliet' balcony, two main suites and a cook's kitchen including skylights, large granite island which is perfect for meal prep or a quick snack, gas stove, trash compactor, ceramic sink and new refrigerator (2023). Remodeled ensuite bedroom on 1st floor boasts full updated bath with heated floors, spacious closet and view of backyard. Spacious upstairs suite features spectacular 'spa bath' where you can relax in soaker tub and enjoy a view of the treetops, a step-in shower, designer dual mirrors & sinks, and a HUGE walk-in closet! This room also has an a/c booster. Finished basement with new vinyl plank flooring is the perfect space for game/movie night! Move-in ready - roof 2021 and exterior paint 2022.

11625 Sea Star Way, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE. Selling Office: Trueblood Real Estate.

$1,450,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths

Stunning waterfront, walk-out Geist home in HSE Schools! SPECTACULAR .7 acre, wooded cul-de-sac lot with 235' of coveted, private water frontage + wraparound walkway & boat dock w/lift & canopy! Entertain on 86' of screened & open decks, plus 2 paver patios & lush yard! You'll LOVE the soaring ceilings, abundant windows, custom millwork, fresh & refined design details & NEW carpet. Main lvl Owner's Retreat w/gorgeous ensuite & private exit to rear deck w/serene water views + ideal main lvl guest suite or home office. Kitchen boasts Viking range & SubZero ref, opens to cozy hearth room w/one of 2 FP's in the home & exits to the vaulted, screened-in deck. Recently remodeled bsmt w/wet bar, rec room, billiards & huge exercise room. A MUST SEE!

9806 Gulfstream Court, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$539,999

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

This 3-bedroom house offers a serene retreat with double doors in the primary suite opening onto a deck. Enjoy direct access to Geist Reservoir through an easement. The walk-out basement and spacious loft overlooking the great room create a fantastic space for entertaining. Stay cozy with two gas log fireplaces and take advantage of the natural gas hook-up on the large deck. Relax in the sunroom, taking in the beauty of the mature, tree-filled backyard. Located in a peaceful area, yet conveniently close to Geist restaurants and attractions, this home is the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience. Don't miss this opportunity to make this your forever home!

11717 Gulfstream Drive, Fishers

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

Masthead, Fishers, IN Recently Sold Homes

Newest Masthead, Fishers, IN Recently Sold Homes

M.O.V.E

Search

Resources

About