Shelby County, IN Real Estate Search

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

The Real Estate Market in Shelby County, IN

Shelby County, Indiana, is a booming area for real estate with a variety of housing options available. From historic homes in charming downtown areas to modern developments in suburban neighborhoods, there is something for everyone in this diverse market. The median home price in Shelby County is currently around $170,000, making it an affordable option for first-time homebuyers and growing families.

Popular Neighborhoods in Shelby County

Some of the most sought-after neighborhoods in Shelby County include the city of Shelbyville, known for its quaint downtown and historic homes, and the town of Fairland, with its rural atmosphere and spacious properties. Other popular areas include Waldron and Morristown, both offering a mix of rural and suburban living options. Whether you're looking for a quiet country retreat or a bustling urban lifestyle, Shelby County has a neighborhood to suit your needs.

Market Trends in Shelby County

The real estate market in Shelby County has been steadily growing over the past few years, with an increase in both home sales and property values. The average days on the market for homes in Shelby County is currently around 60 days, indicating a high demand for housing in the area. With a strong economy and low unemployment rate, Shelby County is a desirable location for both homebuyers and investors looking to capitalize on the growing market.

Up-and-Coming Developments in Shelby County

Several new residential and commercial developments are in the works in Shelby County, including the expansion of retail and dining options in downtown areas and the construction of new housing developments in growing suburbs. With an emphasis on sustainable and eco-friendly design, these developments are attracting buyers looking for modern amenities and energy-efficient homes. As these projects continue to progress, Shelby County is expected to see a further increase in property values and market growth.

Investment Opportunities in Shelby County

For investors looking to capitalize on the growing real estate market in Shelby County, there are numerous opportunities available. From fixer-upper properties in up-and-coming neighborhoods to commercial developments in high-traffic areas, there are plenty of options for those looking to generate passive income or build their real estate portfolio. With a strong rental market and a steady influx of new residents, Shelby County is a prime location for real estate investment opportunities.

Our website features the best Shelby County, IN real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

Avg. No of Beds
Avg. No of Baths
Avg. Living Ft2
Avg. Listing Price
Cost per ft2
Days on Market

Curious about what’s happening in the Shelby County, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Shelby County, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

$150,000
2 Beds 1 Baths
Experience Timeless Charm! This inviting home is a true reflection of quality craftsmanship and lasting appeal. Lovingly cared for by the same owners since 1978, this 1900-built house is ready for you to uncover its classic character. Step into 1,264 square feet of history, where vintage details abound. From the original hardwoods under the carpet to the classic doors, hardware, and large moldings, this home boasts tall ceilings and an undeniable sense of warmth, waiting to continue its story. The roomy front living area and cozy sitting space are perfect for relaxing or spending time with friends and family. Just off the kitchen, the dining room retains its original light fixtures, adding to the home's nostalgic feel. The well-kept kitchen offers a balance of vintage charm with plenty of room for updates to suit your style. With two spacious bedrooms, one bathroom, a practical mudroom, and plenty of storage, this home blends comfort and convenience. Outside, you'll find an oversized one-car garage and an additional lot that brings the total property size to .30 acres. Whether you need space for storage, a workshop, or want to start a garden under the shade of the mature sugar maple trees, this outdoor space offers endless possibilities. Located just a few miles from Morristown and within 20 minutes of Shelbyville, Greenfield, or New Palestine, this charming piece of Gwynneville history provides both a welcoming community and easy access to nearby towns. A great opportunity to own a piece of the past, this home is priced affordably and sold "as is." Recent updates include a serviced furnace, a new sump pump, and new porch steps. Don't miss out on making this delightful home yours!

7111 E US Highway 52, Gwynneville

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$435,000
5 Beds 3 Baths
BETTER THAN BUILDING! This 5-bedroom, 3 full-bath light-filled home was built in 2023 and offers over 3,000 square feet of living space AND a 3-car garage! What makes this better than building a new home? The homeowners have invested in meaningful upgrades including interior louvered plantation shutters, a spacious concrete patio, a full rear black aluminum fence, a water softener, and a drinking water filtration system. Beautifully appointed, this home offers a main-level bedroom and full bath, flex space room, and an additional loft. Your inner chef will love this gorgeous kitchen, featuring quartz countertops, a subtle subway tile backsplash, plentiful cabinet storage, stainless steel appliances, and perhaps best of all... a HUGE island with bar seating. The main level open floorplan allows for easy entertaining and the luxury vinyl plank floors make for simple maintenance. Large windows throughout the house provide excellent natural light in every room. Each upper bedroom offers a walk-in closet, cushy carpet, and overhead lighting. The owner's suite is a homeowner's dream with a tray ceiling, lux en suite bath (comfort-height double sink vanity with quart top, walk-in tiled shower with an upgraded glass door, and a private water closet), as well as a massive walk-in closet...which conveniently leads directly into the laundry room (also accessible via a separate hall door.) This picture-perfect home is located in the lovely Clearview neighborhood, steps from Clearwick Park.

1237 Stonehedge Way, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

$324,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome to this stunning, beautifully restored historic train depot, where timeless elegance meets modern convenience! Nestled in the quaint community of Morristown this exceptional property boasts 4+ spacious bedrooms, 3 full baths and a finished basement making it the perfect home for families or those seeking a distinctive living experience. Come prepared to be captivated by its charming facade and rich history. The recent updates, including a brand-new roof, gutters, windows, and siding, ensure that this treasure maintains its classic character while providing all the comforts of contemporary living. The Bones are solid with updated electrical and plumbing as well! Step inside, and you'll be greeted by an inviting Main level layout that seamlessly blends original architectural features with modern finishes. The kitchen is a large "eat-in" space that blends into the Family Room and/or the Screened-Porch - perfect for entertaining or enjoying cozy family meals. The bedrooms on the main and upper levels feature new carpet and each has it's own distinct character. A Bonus Room in the Walk-Out Basement is currently used as a 5th bedroom! Outside, the near 3/4-Acre property boasts a charming yard with gorgeous gardens, ideal for relaxing or hosting gatherings. Imagine sipping your morning coffee on the deck of your choice, surrounded by mature trees and vibrant landscaping. Plus, the proximity to the community park offers additional recreational opportunities and a peaceful walking trail - perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and families. This remarkable home is not just a residence; it's a piece of history waiting to be cherished by its next owner. Don't miss your chance to own a slice of the past while enjoying all the modern amenities you desire. Schedule a showing today and experience the charm and character of this one-of-a-kind historic train depot! USDA Financing Approved. It's practical too with Exterior Storage Barn & Attached Storage Shed!

317 N Morrison Street, Morristown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$297,900
3 Beds 3 Baths
This spacious home rests on a cul-de-sac with a fenced rear yard, close to walking and bike paths. The generously sized rooms are nice for those large furniture items. The front room in the home could be split as a dining room and sitting room. The large mud room & pantry room off of the kitchen and garage is large enough that could be an office area on one side and pantry on the other. The eat-in kitchen features cherry cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and additional cabinet/counter area for a dry bar/coffee area. The great room is large enough could be split and enclosed for an additional bedroom. The laundry room upstairs next to the bedrooms makes it easy for a quick wash/dry of needed items. The over-sized primary bedroom features a large bathroom with recessed area for a walk-in shower or prep area. The extra long primary closet is large enough to be considered a small room. Updates include recent new 1 layer roof, updated appliances, water heater less than 1 year old, Water softener less than 2 years old, updating some painting, deck railing, and more. Additional interior touch up painting being completed and some minor trim repair. Fall evenings can be enjoyed from your covered porch or your rear deck that features a fully fenced rear yard, mini barn, fire pit, and views of the ponds, walking and biking trails. This property is close to amenities, grocery store, schools, shopping, and parks. 5 minutes from I-74.

1472 Valdosta Court, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$274,900
5 Beds 3 Baths
In the heart of the bustling town, where cobblestone sidewalks echo with the whispers of time, there stands a home of Victorian grace, stately and grand, ensconced in nature's embrace. Its weathered brick facade speaks of stories untold, while ivy tendrils caress its walls with an air of ancient romance. Tall windows with lace curtains catch the morning light, casting dappled shadows upon hardwood floors that have known the tread of many generations. Within its walls, four spacious chambers lie, each a sanctuary of repose, where the scent of lavender lingers in the air, mingling with the soft glow of a crackling hearth. Ornate moldings and rich tapestries adorn the halls, each turn revealing a new delight, a secret waiting to be uncovered. A kitchen with a hearth of its own beckons with the promise of warm bread and hearty stew, while a dining room fit for the most distinguished of guests awaits evenings filled with laughter and song. Step outside, and the home gives way to a wooded glen, a verdant retreat where ancient oaks whisper to the sky and squirrels dart through the underbrush in a playful ballet. Here, amidst the embrace of nature, one may find solace from the bustling town beyond, a refuge where time itself seems to stand still. This Victorian treasure, with its perfect blend of elegance and nature, offers not just a home, but a haven-centrally located in the heart of downtown, yet a world apart, where the past meets the present, and the soul finds its peace...

47 E Mechanic Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®