Shelby County, IN Real Estate Search

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

The Real Estate Market in Shelby County, IN

Shelby County, Indiana, is a booming area for real estate with a variety of housing options available. From historic homes in charming downtown areas to modern developments in suburban neighborhoods, there is something for everyone in this diverse market. The median home price in Shelby County is currently around $170,000, making it an affordable option for first-time homebuyers and growing families.

Popular Neighborhoods in Shelby County

Some of the most sought-after neighborhoods in Shelby County include the city of Shelbyville, known for its quaint downtown and historic homes, and the town of Fairland, with its rural atmosphere and spacious properties. Other popular areas include Waldron and Morristown, both offering a mix of rural and suburban living options. Whether you're looking for a quiet country retreat or a bustling urban lifestyle, Shelby County has a neighborhood to suit your needs.

Market Trends in Shelby County

The real estate market in Shelby County has been steadily growing over the past few years, with an increase in both home sales and property values. The average days on the market for homes in Shelby County is currently around 60 days, indicating a high demand for housing in the area. With a strong economy and low unemployment rate, Shelby County is a desirable location for both homebuyers and investors looking to capitalize on the growing market.

Up-and-Coming Developments in Shelby County

Several new residential and commercial developments are in the works in Shelby County, including the expansion of retail and dining options in downtown areas and the construction of new housing developments in growing suburbs. With an emphasis on sustainable and eco-friendly design, these developments are attracting buyers looking for modern amenities and energy-efficient homes. As these projects continue to progress, Shelby County is expected to see a further increase in property values and market growth.

Investment Opportunities in Shelby County

For investors looking to capitalize on the growing real estate market in Shelby County, there are numerous opportunities available. From fixer-upper properties in up-and-coming neighborhoods to commercial developments in high-traffic areas, there are plenty of options for those looking to generate passive income or build their real estate portfolio. With a strong rental market and a steady influx of new residents, Shelby County is a prime location for real estate investment opportunities.

Our website features the best Shelby County, IN real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

Avg. No of Beds
Avg. No of Baths
Avg. Living Ft2
Avg. Listing Price
Cost per ft2
Days on Market

Curious about what’s happening in the Shelby County, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Shelby County, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

4 Beds 3 Baths
One-of-a-kind true custom French Country home on five and a half acres with plenty of privacy! Nestled in the perfect location only 30+ minutes from downtown Indianapolis or minutes from Columbus, be prepared to be in awe of this stunning all-brick 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home on a meticulously maintained landscaped estate. This beauty will impress you the minute you turn into the driveway and is designed for entertaining and family interaction. A raised and open entry leads to the formal living room, formal dining room, home office or family room. Talk about a welcoming entry to your home! The custom touches are everywhere you turn and include arched entry doors, hardwood floors, exposed wood beams, an oversized limestone fireplace and a wall of French doors leading to the tiled patio and courtyard with a fountain. The chef's eat-in kitchen boasts upgraded appliances including a gas range/griddle, double ovens, refrigerator, and custom cabinetry in addition to the center island and closet pantry, which leads into the main level laundry room. The secluded primary suite on the main level has vaulted ceilings, a spa bath, and French doors to the courtyard patio and walk-in dressing room. Three additional bedrooms and a huge playroom give you plenty of sleeping areas. The basement is ready for your finishing touches and is a great area for storage. The outdoor spaces with this estate are some of the most impressive! A true French garden area right off the family room, a private hot tub area plus the addition of the exterior patio with a pergola, and a large brick fireplace create an ideal entertaining space and a perfect relaxation area to end the day. For those who love to be one with nature, you will find an additional metal-covered space for picnics and or a fire pit which would make a great camp-feel area for nature lovers. With too many features to list, this home is a must-see to truly appreciate. Don't wait, call for your private viewing today

10338 S Auburn Hills Drive, Edinburgh

Listing courtesy of United Real Estate Indpls.

3 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome to your dream home! Nestled in a sought-after rural area in Shelby County, Triton Schools, this beautiful property has been lovingly maintained by the same owner for 26 years. This home features 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms, Den and spacious living for your family with generously sized rooms to provide a comfortable and open living environment. Large kitchen with center island for easy entertaining with ample counter/cabinet space, a large eat in kitchen area, and walk in pantry. The 9 Acre lot has plenty of space for outdoor activities, gardening, and enjoying nature. A 40x60 pole Barn is perfect for storage, workshops, or hobbyists. This home also has an 18x28 seperate jacuzzi room right off the lower back deck which includes an 8x8 jacuzzi and plenty of space for a bar and the outdoor paver patio has room for furniture with a firepit. The 2 level deck on the back of the home offers plenty of space for grilling and sitting around to enjoy nature and the wildlife that visits the yard. Sit out front on the paver patio and enjoy the koi ponds and waterfall. The open back acreage leads to a wooded area that spans the width of the property, with Sugar Creek right behind the woods. There is a large alcove at the rear of the property that leads to the creek. During the warmer months, enjoy the above ground Kayak saltwater pool (practically maintenance free). This property offers the perfect blend of rural charm and modern amenities. Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat or a place to create lasting memories with your family like the current owner has done, this home has it all. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity to own in sought after Shelby County. This type of property does not come available often! Schedule a viewing today! See attachments for items that convey with property, that are for sale/negotiable with strong offer, and recent upgrades/improvements. Pre-list inspection done and items corrected.

11335 N 600 W, Fountaintown

Listing courtesy of Crossroads Real Estate Group LLC.

3 Beds 1 Baths
Old charm and country feel for this incredible property. Use your imagination to bring this traditional farmhouse style home back to life.There is updating and remodeling to do keep that in mind. "Small" primary bedroom is on the main level. Resting nicely on 3.20 acres you have a circular driveway for plenty of parking, horse barn with electric. Barn has had extra support beams added but still in need of additional work to be a functioning barn. Huge mature trees, large front porch to enjoy relaxing during the summer evenings and walking distance (literally across the street) to Blue River Park. This home was a true gem back in its day. Main level offers a large living room with free standing fireplace, formal dining room, one full bath, large eat-in kitchen with tons of storage, counter space and cabinets, laundry room with built-in cabinets, bonus room off of the laundry room is a perfect mud room or space for canning those veggies from the garden, two upper-level bedrooms (limited closet space / and pitched ceilings). Adding to the charm notice the glass shelves on both sides of the door in the dining room, original solid wood doors. The home has newer carpet in the living / dining room and newer windows in the home. Some TLC is needed to update the home for the next family. There is also a 12x30 four season room for additional living space. The window unit is not operational and no heat to this room. Two car attached garage. This home will be Sold As-Is, no repairs will be done by the seller. No FHA or VA offers. Seller has not lived in the home for many years and true condition is unknown.

1034 E Morris Avenue, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Steve Lew Real Estate Group, LLC.

3 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome to your new luxury ranch home in beautiful Shelbyville, IN! This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom residence spans over 2,000 square feet and is loaded with premium features that combine elegance and comfort. As you approach, you'll notice the additional brick adorning the sides and rear of the home, providing a classic and refined touch. Step inside and immediately feel the warmth of the gas corner fireplace in the spacious great room, perfect for cozy evenings with family and friends. The insulated garage, complete with a stylish door featuring windows, ensures your vehicles stay protected and adds a touch of sophistication to the exterior. Natural light floods the home through the generous 6' tall windows, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere throughout. The open-concept living area flows seamlessly into the gourmet kitchen, where you'll find 42" upper cabinetry in a chic ivory finish, equipped with modern cabinet hardware. The 3 CM quartz countertops and 3x6 tiled backsplash provide a sleek and durable workspace, while the kitchen island offers additional prep space and seating for casual dining. You'll appreciate the convenience of the gas line to the range, the backless smudge-proof slide-in gas range, chimney range hood, and the black dishwasher, making meal prep and clean-up a breeze. An under-sink water filtration system ensures clean and fresh water for your family. Step outside to the expansive 18'x18' rear concrete patio, ideal for outdoor entertaining or simply enjoying a quiet evening under the stars. The primary suite is a true retreat, featuring a deluxe garden bath tub and a separate shower for a spa-like experience. Quartz countertops in all bathrooms and luxury vinyl plank flooring in the common areas add to the luxurious feel of this home. Additional features include a 50-gallon, 90% efficiency power vent gas water heater, a water softener bypass rough-in, and extra lighting and electrical throughout the home for your comfort

1156 Breckinridge Way, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

3 Beds 3 Baths
Hard to find over 6 very useable acres and a roomy, updated comfortable Ranch style house with large finished basement in the very desirable Triton Central district. The covered front porch and multi-level back decks to watch the sun set, enjoy the firefies, see the occasional deer wander through your back acres, or entertain if you feel so inclined. Inside, you will find special touches throughout the house. The fully remodeled kitchen opens into the dining area, flowing seamlessly to the upstairs living room. Just off the kitchen is the laundry/utility room which also has a large pantry. there is a special water filter/conditioner dedicated to the washer there, although the current owners have not used it. There is new flooring throughout the house. The master bedroom down the hall on the main floor has a lovely view of the back acreage, and an in suite master bathroom featuring a separate shower, a whirlpool tub, double sinks, and a tall storage cabinet. It is also at the opposite end of the house from the other 2 bedrooms for a bit more privacy. The basement offers a 2 car attached garage, a really large family room with a huge storage space behind the new stylish doors, and two other versatile bonus rooms. Recently installed are new roof ( 1yr) , new siding, some new windows, new kitchen ( 6mo), new flooring throughout; new doors, new light fixtures, upgraded full bath in basement; SO much storage space, outside, too! A detached garage with dirt and stone floor was previously used for horse stables; a very large pole barn with dirt floor contains utility posts and fencing to put back up if someone wants horses or livestock, and MORE storage! The curving driveway to the house is the gateway to your new sanctuary!

5209 N Frontage Road, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Culmann Real Estate Group, LLC.

5 Beds 5 Baths
Stunning 20+ Acre Estate on Snail Creek in Fairland, IN. Located 35 minutes from downtown Indianapolis. Discover unparalleled luxury and tranquility in this estate located over 1/4 mile off the county road. Perfectly blending modern amenities with natural beauty for an exceptional retreat for those seeking both comfort and adventure. Seven acres of the property are for crop land with the remainder featuring a beautifully landscaped lawn and lush woods offering privacy and natural beauty. Spacious living with over 10,000 square feet of living space with six bedrooms, four full baths, two 1/2 baths, two laundry rooms and mud room off of the main floor garage. The home office and sunroom on the main floor add versatility and comfort to the living space. The large gourmet kitchen with a walk in pantry provides ample space for cooking and storage. The home theater, indoor racquetball room and a basement recreation area are perfect for gatherings and entertaining. For outside activities you can enjoy a basketball court and tennis court. There are two play cabins with lofts and a fenced backyard with a redwood playground for children to play outdoors safely. There are two storage rooms, a seven car garage and heated garage area. A breezeway connects the main house to the garage for convenience. Enjoy the warmth of three fireplaces, a wraparound porch and covered back porch for relaxation and enjoying the views. The home was recently updated with new geothermal furnaces, new roof and new water heater. The property also has walking trails and scenic views including a small apple orchard. This property is a rare find offering a unique combination of luxury, functionality and natural beauty in a picturesque setting. Whether you're looking for a serene escape or an entertainer's paradise, this estate has it all.

3917 N 525 W, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Vintage Realty, Inc..

3 Beds 2 Baths
The GREATEST value in all of Shelbyville and Shelby County!!! This home exemplifies pride of ownership and pride in craftsmanship. You have to see it with your own eyes to completely understand. It all starts with the hardy plank siding in the perfect shade of blue. Sprawling covered porch in the front and massive deck in the back for your outdoor living paradise. The windows speak for themselves with the highest quality product all while maintaining the original beautiful craftsmanship and abundance of natural light. The classic craftsman wood trim and wood doors still bless this property with copious character. The beautifully finished hard wood floors give the home the sturdy feel and look of a classic Victorian home. The spacious main level living room and formal dining room will fit the bill for all the biggest family gatherings. The updated kitchen is the perfect blend of modern meets Victorian with more than enough counter space for the largest meal preparations in addition to the kitchen island. The main level utility room is where you will find the laundry hook ups with built in shelves to keep every household well organized. The main level bathroom is simple yet elegant and the shower is richly tiled floor to ceiling. The upstairs bathroom is extremely large with a soaker jacuzzi tub. 3 Bedrooms upstairs where you will find a bedroom with a hand crafted built in bed. Mechanicals were thoughtfully replaced with a higher efficiency gas furnace and air conditioning and an On-Demand natural gas tankless water heater. And YES there is a two car detached garage for the auto enthusiast or those who want there own private space away from the house. This garage would make a perfect home shop for a hobbyist looking for an insulated and fully finished work space that happens to have its own 100 amp service with a window A/C unit. This home is a must see and will make the perfect next chapter for any family.

1131 S Harrison Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Fathom Realty.

3 Beds 3 Baths
If you're looking for luxury in the country, look no further! Check out this gorgeous all brick home on 3 beautiful acres! The open, airy floor plan includes skylights, beautiful wood windows, crown molding and soaring ceilings! The impressive stone fireplace serves as a focal point in the spacious living area creating an inviting ambiance for relaxation and entertainment. With a focus on functionality and style, the kitchen stands as the heart of the home, boasting 42" cabinets, a center island, and sleek ceramic flooring, providing a perfect setting for culinary endeavors or casual dining with loved ones. The attached 2-car garage not only provides shelter for vehicles but also offers a convenient workbench for DIY projects or hobbies. The owner's suite has spa-like features, including a stand up shower equipped with a built-in sound system, massage shower heads, and elegant recessed lighting, creating a retreat within your own home. Meanwhile, the bonus room upstairs presents an opportunity for customization, whether as an additional bedroom, a home office, or a recreational space to suit your preferences. The yard is beautifully landscaped and enclosed by a new privacy fence, creating an oasis for both relaxation and recreation. The fire-pit area invites gatherings under the stars, fostering unforgettable moments with friends and family. Enjoy fresh picked apples, peach, pecans, and blackberries from the trees! The recent updates in 2023, including the furnace, air conditioner, water softener, gutters, soffits, downspouts, trim, and fresh paint, signify a commitment to modern comfort and maintenance, ensuring a worry-free experience for the new owners. Seize the chance to experience the perfect blend of country living and relaxing comfort. Schedule your showing today!

4325 N 400 W, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

3 Beds 4 Baths
Historic 1870's Italianate Farm House on 16 Acres w/ Barn, Pasture, Private Forest & 5 Miles of View!! This One-Of-A-Kind Property has been Completely Renovated w/ High Attention to Craftsmanship & Modern Engineering Standards...all While Retaining its Original Architectural Elegance. The Home Features: 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms, Grand Formal Living Room/Parlor, Dining Room, Office/Den, Summer Kitchen, 3 Fireplaces, Laundry/Mud Room & 11Ft Ceilings w/ Over 3500 Square Feet of Finished Living Space; Plus a Basement, Unfinished 3rd Floor, Roof-Top Widow's Walk & 3 Separate Porches. Original Woodwork & Details Have Been Painstakingly Refinished...Ornate Handcrafted Entry Doors, Hardwood Floors, 9ft Interior Doors, Trim, Hardware, Fireplaces, Shutters, Built-in Hutch, Grand Staircase, Plaster Walls, Plaster Medallions & Plaster Crown Moldings all Retain Their 1870's Grandeur. Updated Kitchen w/ Hardwood Cabinets, Center Island, Granite Countertops & an Original Fireplace. Updated Bathrooms Have Mosaic Tile Floors, Updated Vanities & a Claw Foot Free Standing Bathtub. Mechanical Updates/Upgrades Include: Dual System Geo-Thermal Heat Pumps, Commercial Standing Seam Metal Roof, Insulted Windows, Well Pump, Closed Cell Foam Insulation, Plumbing, 400 Amp Electrical Service & Much More! The Barn Features: 60'x70' Post Frame Free Span Construction Divided into 10'x60' Stables, 3 Car Garage, 2,700 Square Foot Workshop, 20'x40' Finished Space w/ Full Bathroom & Kitchenette. Property Features Include: 15.74 Acres Spread Across 2 Parcels...7 of Those Acres Feature the Home, the Barn & Pasture; the Remaining Acreage is Private Forest. This Property is Full of Rich History, from its Beginning has a 900 Acre Farm House to the Modern County Lifestyle for Today...this Home was Built & Restored to Stand The Test of Time, it's Just Amazing!

7955 W 400 N, Boggstown

Listing courtesy of Red Oak Real Estate Group.

4 Beds 2 Baths
This beautiful colonial style home sitting on a corner lot with full front porch is waiting for new owners. Located within walking distance to park, bike trails and the heart of Downtown Shelbyville. Beautiful stained woodwork, some is painted. Original hardwood floors throughout. 4 Bedrooms, 2 full baths( both newly remodeled) . 2 original fireplaces are still in home. One has been converted into gas log with remote in front living room. Dining is still coal and both have been inspected and are functional. Butler staircase from upper level to kitchen with beautiful wooden staircase in large front foyer. 10 ft first floor ceilings, 9 ft second floor ceilings. Primary bedroom on main floor with full bath right next to it. Could be in laws room if you wanted to use other large bedroom as primary. Large walk in area could be finished out for den and the entire attic above 2nd floor is open and large enough to be finished out with another bedroom or two. Built with Native lumber, she has great bones and could be restored to original beauty with little effort. Platted in 1823. Owner also has blueprints and drawings for one car garage that could be added on to the home. They had planned to do just that and ran out of time to do it. Front porch has 2 porch swings and view of beautiful Davis Mansion. Steps to porch were done within the past year or two. You will not be disappointed in this home with its natural beauty and old character. First floor also has back porch area that was possible used as a canning room or other area with a door to outside and a door to the home.

56 W Mechanic Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®