Refine Search
Sort by
$823,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Stunning lake views! This beautiful home greets you with a large welcoming foyer open to the great room with masonry hearth, cathedral ceilings and floor to ceiling windows. The kitchen opens to great room and dining room and offers granite countertops, updated cabinets and seated bar area. Enjoy meals and relaxation on the screened-in porch or on the deck. Primary suite offers its own access to the screened-in porch, walk-in closet, private w/c with tub and separate shower. In this split floor plan, you'll find the second bedroom with its own access to the mail level deck. Massive lower level greets you with more floor to ceiling windows. Wide open for your creativity on the finish. Plumbed for a full bath. Floor plans show a fourth bedroom. Outfitted with a Generac whole house generator. Pre-inspection and professional photos will be available in a day or two. SHOWING BEGIN AT 3:30 DECEMBER 16TH. This is lake living you won't want to miss!

866 S Lanyard Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of United Real Estate Indpls. Selling Office: United Real Estate Indpls.

$285,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
This tastefully updated home in Arcadia sits on a very large, corner lot just a short walk from downtown. The home features a nice covered front porch with a beautiful double-door entry to the home. Once inside, you'll find a spacious entryway and a home office space in the front. The master suite is on the main floor and the bathroom features a walk-in shower. As you continue through the downstairs, you will find an open concept living room/kitchen arrangement. The eat-in kitchen is extra large with tons of cabinet space, beautiful white cabinets, an island with eating area, quartz counters and stainless steel appliances. Rounding out the downstairs includes a half bath and utility room with the laundry area and included washer and dryer, plenty of storage space. The upstairs includes three additional bedrooms and a full bathroom as well. Off from the kitchen is a great deck with a partial cover for shade for your summertime gatherings. The backyard is fully fenced and there is plenty of room for a game of cornhole, volleyball or simply grilling out with family and friends. The home also features a two-car, attached garage. There is an additional gravel drive in front for guest parking. Updates in 2022 include new siding, all 25 windows and gutters with leaf guards.

100 W North Street, Arcadia

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

$274,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home blends historic charm with modern convenience, offering a welcoming and versatile space for its next owner. The enclosed front porch, complete with a swing and additional seating, adds character and opens to a spacious, inviting great room. The stainless kitchen features Craftsman-style cabinetry, a pantry, quartz countertops, a coffee and breakfast bar, and an adjacent breakfast room. A versatile dining or flex room, complete with built-in cabinetry, offers endless possibilities. The main-level primary and guest bedrooms, along with the upper-level bedroom and adjacent office or nursery, provide flexible living options for everyone. Sleek, tiled bathrooms add a dramatic touch, while the laundry room, equipped with a washer and dryer, balances style and functionality. You'll love the heated all-seasons room, the herringbone paver patio with a fire pit, and the fully fenced yard - perfect for entertaining or relaxation. Just blocks from Morse Reservoir, this home offers easy access to Cicero's best amenities and waterfront experiences. Red Bridge Park, with its marina and scenic trails, is a short stroll away, while Jackson Street provides a vibrant corridor of local eateries and shops with a variety of dining options. Convenient access to SR-31 and SR-19 makes traveling a breeze. With contemporary colors, warm-toned flooring, recessed lighting, thermal, double-hung windows, complete with blinds, an ample garage, and plenty of storage, there's nothing missing but you!

149 N Harrison Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Indy's Performance Team Realty. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$350,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Motivated seller! With over 2600 sf., this spacious 4 BR, 2.5 BA home is located in desirable Tamarack Subdivision in the quaint lake town of Cicero. Home offers a bright living room and a cozy family room filled with natural light, offering comfort and style. The family room flows effortlessly into the open-concept kitchen and dining area, creating the perfect space for entertaining. The kitchen features a large island, stainless steel appliances, and a built-in coffee bar. Bedrooms are located upstairs and nicely separated for privacy and easy access to a versatile loft area and 2nd floor laundry room. Situated on a large corner lot, this property provides a generous yard, perfect for outdoor entertainment and pets. Enjoy recreational paths, a community pool and pool house, and playground. With quick access to downtown Cicero and Morse Reservoir, your family can enjoy a variety of excellent restaurants and shopping options. For the nature and cycling enthusiasts, just a few miles away is the 750 acre Strawtown Koteewi Park that features a canoe launch on the White River, boating and fishing opportunities, nature trails for hiking and cycling, equestrian trails, and beautiful wetlands and prairies. Don't miss the chance to make this home yours-schedule a showing today!

203 Alvor Court, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$360,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome to this meticulously maintained 4-bedroom, 2-story home in the charming golf cart community of Cicero, Indiana. Nestled in a peaceful neighborhood, this residence offers a perfect blend of modern comfort and timeless appeal. As you enter, you're greeted by natural light from large windows through the home highlighting the functional floor plan of the home. The inviting living room flows seamlessly into the well-appointed kitchen, complete with stainless steel appliances, ample cabinetry, and pantry. The main floor also features a formal dining area that overlooks the beautifully landscaped front yard, creating a serene dining experience. A convenient half-bath and a dedicated laundry room round out this level. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, each offering plenty of closet space and comfortable carpeted flooring. Step outside to discover a meticulously maintained backyard, complete with a spacious patio perfect for summer barbecues and outdoor gatherings. The lush lawn and large trees offer a tranquil space to relax complete with a shed for storage. Additional features include a two-car garage with bump out and a well-maintained exterior with charming curb appeal. This home is just minutes from local parks, shopping, and numerous dining options, most of which is accessible by the walking path just steps from the home. Whether its pickle ball or kayaking, both are possible in friendly lakeside town of Cicero. Don't miss the opportunity to make this stunning home yours! 1/89 ownership in the common area located on the west side of Stringtown Pike across from the south entrance of Lincoln drive. The common area features large lot as well as lake access for fishing or swimming.

1373 Sherman Circle, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Wise Choice Real Estate LLC.

$355,000
2 Beds 2 Baths
Newer ranch patio home with open floor plan and stunning outdoor living space! Main floor primary bedroom with spacious bath and closet plus additional main floor bedroom and full bath! Kitchen with eat in area is ready for home cooked meals or family time gathering around the large island! Abundant closet/storage space on main level! Upstairs features a large bonus room with full wet bar (wine fridge, ice maker, humidor, kegerator with lines run, dishwasher & full fridge), perfect gathering place to host friends and family for a holiday or Sunday football game! Step outside to your private backyard oasis with stamped concrete patio, hot tub, pergola, professional landscaping and spacious outdoor dining area! Rain Bird irrigation system with bonus flower pot drip irrigation! All furnishings are available to stay with the home! Drive your golf cart to dinner, ice cream or Morse Reservoir! Access to Tamarack neighborhood pool & playground!

264 Perlican Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

$1,265,000
5 Beds 5 Baths
If you've ever wanted to live on Morse Reservoir on 1.5 wooded acres in a Hallmark movie-worthy home, THIS IS IT!!! You will fall in love with the private cul-de-sac location, the inviting wrap around front porch, 3 car attached garage, and best of all - the indoor pool with a gorgeous glass solarium you can use year round! Enter the bright, inviting and large living room with a Vermont Castings fireplace insert and follow around toward the updated kitchen with gleaming copper sinks, updated appliances, and plenty of seating at the island or breakfast room. This leads to a large family room overlooking the solarium and outdoor deck - take in the views of over an acre of tree-filled, gently sloping hillside leading to a sturdy composite dock, 160 feet of water frontage with a galvanized steel sea wall, and a RARE gazebo structure overlooking the water. All this, PLUS a detached 2 car garage/workshop/boat storage outside. Inside, you'll find 4 generous second floor bedrooms with a large loft, updated bathrooms, a wonderful storage system in the laundry room, a finished basement with an additional bedroom, full bathroom, AND a tornado shelter/safe room. Homes like this don't come along often - don't miss your chance to own your "forever" property on Morse Reservoir!

71 Forest Hollow Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Elliott Real Estate.

$379,900
3 Beds 2 Baths
Discover this rare gem built in 2020, nestled on 1.5 acres of serene countryside just outside the charming town of Arcadia. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home combines modern comfort with a peaceful, rural lifestyle-perfect for creating your own hobby farm, all without HOA restrictions. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan, featuring a spacious great room with a cozy gas fireplace that flows seamlessly into a beautiful kitchen with plenty of cabinetry. Equipped with stainless steel appliances, a large island, and a walk-in pantry, the kitchen also offers a sunny breakfast nook and a versatile sitting area, ideal for entertaining or relaxing. The master suite provides a private retreat, separated from the other bedrooms, and includes a private bath and a roomy walk-in closet. Completing this wonderful home is an oversized 2-car garage with plenty of extra space for storage. Embrace a lifestyle of comfort and freedom in this beautiful countryside retreat.

27002 Arcadia Road, Arcadia

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Edge. Selling Office: RE/MAX Edge.

$305,900
3 Beds 2 Baths
Location Location!! This is the Home you have been looking for in the Desirable Lakeside Town of Cicero! You will love this awesome location with just a stones throw to Morse Reservoir, just steps to the walking path, Community Park with Pickleball! Amazing Stone Ranch with Ready for the New Owner to make it their own! Open floor plan offers 3 Beds, 2 Full Baths with Separate Office space. Amazing Kitchen space and Breakfast area with Cozy Gas Log fireplace. (Chimney cleaned 2022) You will enjoy the Large Corner Lot with Mature Trees and Fenced Backyard. HUGE Storage Barn with Huge Loft space and Electricity would be perfect for that Extra Storage Space, Golf Cart or mower! Oversized 2 Car Garage with workshop area and deep sink. Jump on your Golf Cart and Cruise to the Local Restaurants, Boutiques, Public Lake access at Red Bridge Park for Kayaking and Fishing! Roof 6-7 years, Furnace/AC 6 years, Range, Microwave and Dishwasher 1 year old. Do not pass this one by, GREAT LOCATION!!!

1269 Shoreline Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$901,500
3 Beds 3 Baths
Morse Waterfront! Beautifully updated Morse Lake home with freshly painted exterior (2024)! Step into your great room with one of the best views on the lake! Cook with your family gathered at the large island with gas cooktop or hop on your boat and float to dinner! Open concept main floor with updated kitchen (double ovens, farmhouse sink, under cabinet microwave) plus pantry and large eat in area. 2 main floor bedrooms share a newly renovated bath with custom tile walk in shower! Owners suite upstairs with gigantic footprint bath/closet! Walk out lower level is ready for you to finish out with plumbing, toilet, and laundry already in place! Potential for second living space, full bar, 4th bedroom, workout room or lake toy storage! Endless possibilities! No expense spared on the lakeside! Expanded large composite deck, fire pit with sunset views, stamped concrete boardwalk & new seawall! New composite dock with 2 boat slips, 5000lb covered boat lift with canopy top (in storage for the winter season) and new jet ski port! 2 kayaks & paddle board included! A short golf cart ride to quaint downtown Cicero.

1460 Lighthouse Point, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

$240,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome Home to the Charming Lakeside Community of Cicero Indiana! Do NOT miss this updated, ALL BRICK ranch in OLD TOWN Cicero! This home is in walking distance to the downtown restaurants, shops and Morse Reservoir. This Amazing home is Move-in ready with All new paint, carpet, flooring, NEW Kitchen, Updated Baths, NEW Roof, New Windows and More. 3 Bedroom offers flex space that could be a Home Office or playroom. Spacious Corner Lot with Patio, Large Storage shed, Extra parking space is great for Camper or Boat parking. Spacious Garage with Workshop/storage space! Golf Cart Friendly Town with Public Lake access for Kayak and Lake fishing at RED BRIDGE PARK. Watch the 4th of July Parade right from your own yard and a short walk to see the fireworks over the Lake!! This home is CHARMING and just what you are looking for. Welcome HOME!!

269 Wiley Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$395,000
5 Beds 3 Baths
Come tour this ALMOST BRAND NEW HOME!!! In a Lake Community and ONLY 2 years old with 8 years left of its Home Warranty!!! The UPGRADES speak for itself. Entering the Foyer with a main level bedroom or office. Full Bathroom and Open floor plan. Large Custom kitchen for entertaining. Quartz countertops, kitchen island, full appliance package, loads of counter space!!! Relax in the sunroom area and look outside or enjoy yourself in the Hot Tub that stays!! Continuing upstairs to a Loft, Master suite, 3 more spacious bedrooms, 3rd full bathroom and laundry room. The expansive master suite has double vanity, separate shower and tub and walk in closet. This home is located in Auburn Estates with a community playground. Close to lake activities, shopping, eating, and relaxation!! click on the tour!

10 Hollister Way, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Trueblood Real Estate. Selling Office: Envoy Real Estate, LLC.

$900,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
This expansive 19-acre property offers a unique blend of comfortable living and versatile functionality, perfect for those seeking both space and opportunity. The well-maintained ranch home provides a welcoming environment with plenty of natural light & open living areas. Adjacent to the main house a charming cottage and a carriage house with a living space above a two-car garage offer additional accommodations, making it ideal for multi-generational living, guests, or even rental potential. For those needing extensive storage or workspace, the property includes a detached garage with a lean-to and a large 4-stall garage. Perfect for vehicle storage, equipment, or hobby enthusiasts. The 19 acres of land include a mix of open fields and wooded areas, offering endless possibilities for farming, recreation, or future development. The layout of the property provides flexibility for various uses while maintaining the tranquil rural atmosphere. Whether you're looking to enjoy the serene countryside, expand your business ventures, or simply have room to grow, this property caters to it all.

22412 Voss Hiatt Avenue, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Engel & Volkers. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$450,000
3 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome Home to the Desirable Lakeside Community of Cicero!! Now is your chance to enjoy the Lake Life without breaking the bank! NO HOA! Do not miss this opportunity to live in the Amazing Neighborhood of Morse Landing while having your Own Deeded Boat Dock & Water Access just STEPS from your home. What a life, Wake up on a Saturday morning, grab your Cooler, jump on your boat and FLOAT ALL DAY! Great Dock Location with EASY in and out. You will LOVE this Charming & Stylish home situated on a Beautiful Wooded Lot w/wonderful Winter Views of the Lake. Step inside to the Open 2 Story Great rm that flows perfectly into your Breakfast room and Kitchen area. Main Flr Primary Bedrm offers his & her closets with a private full bath! You will enjoy the Huge home Office Office, FLEX Space that could be used for a 2nd Primary Bedrm, 4th Bedrm,Family rm, Game Room & More. So many options! Spacious upstairs bedrms, walk-in closets PLUS extra Storage space in the Walk-in attic. Relax in the peaceful backyard while sitting around your campfire. Do not forget to check out the extra parking, boat, golf cart, camper storage space & Storage Shed. AC and Water Heater updated 2019, Backyard fence 2020, All New Vinyl Plank, Waterproof flooring, Bath/shower upstairs, Stove/Oven in 2024, Refrig 2022, Replaced Wood framing/siding at fireplace 2021. This home is a Keeper. RARE FIND.

704 Pleasant Point Circle, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$750,000
5 Beds 5 Baths
Custom 5 bed, 4.5 bath home with over 4200 sqft of living space on a almost 1/2 acre lot with lush landscaping AND is walking distance to coveted Morse Reservoir. Step inside this stunning home to find a spacious 2-story foyer with soaring ceilings which opens up to the formal dining room and great room. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's delight with beautiful brick accents, gas oven/range, built-in oven/microwave, built-in refrigerator, granite countertops, tile backsplash and stainless steel appliances. The cozy living room with gas fireplace has floor to ceilings windows allowing tons of natural light. Rest and relax in the primary suite featuring a spa-like en-suite bathroom with custom tile shower, whirlpool tub, double vanity sinks and walk-in closet. Each bedroom is generously sized. The fully finished basement includes a wet bar w/ mini fridge, spacious bedroom and full bath. Enjoy a brand-new HVAC system (2023), new hardwoods and carpet throughout (2024), and a new roof (2023). Community HOA dock is available to boat owners for lake accessibility.

21699 Anchor Bay Drive, Noblesville

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$295,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Charming 4 bed 1.5 bath home with tons of character. Quality craftsmanship, beautiful flooring, tile and craftsman finishes thru out. Main floor owner's suite with jetted tub and walk in closet. Spacious bedrooms with vaulted upstairs. Great farmhouse kitchen with newer appliances, granite countertops, excellent cabinet space, and dining area with mudroom entrance. Wrap-around porch w/ Gingerbread Trim. Gorgeous Landscaping, lots of trees, and plenty of room to spread out. Relax on the new back deck. Huge 3 Car Garage W/ Workshop and an enormous, finished loft over the top of the garage with endless possibilities. Small town charm with easy access to restaurants, shopping and more.

510 Hamilton Avenue, Arcadia

Listing courtesy of EPYK Realty LLC. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

$323,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Welcome home! This beautiful home offers 4 bedroom 2.5 bath with an open floor plan. The kitchen and great room wonderful for entertaining your family and friends. Updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances, generous counter tops, tile backsplash and plenty of cabinets plus a pantry. Gorgeous engineered hardwood flooring through out the main floor. Separate room off the entry could be a dedicated office or even a play area. Upstairs features 4 spacious bedrooms and a loft. Primary bedroom is large enough for a sitting area. Primary bathroom provides double sinks, separate shower and garden tub with beautiful tile work. The additional bedrooms are very spacious with walk in closets. One room has built ins that was used as a sewing/craft room but large enough for a bedroom too. Additionally there is the loft area either for another work area, playroom or just to hang out. Head out back to the privately fenced yard and enjoy your cookouts. This home is part of the wonderful heart of Cicero and offers a unique lake and golf community. Close to Morse Reservoir, great restaurants and shopping areas.

1209 Frogs Leap, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$244,500
3 Beds 1 Baths
Welcome home to Small Town USA! Do not miss out on this CHARMING Ranch home that has SO much charm and character! Desirable Hamilton Heights Schools with easy access to US 31 and SR 19 for Commuting. This home has so much curb appeal with a craftsmans style look. You will enjoy those relaxing evenings sitting in your enclosed Front Porch. The charm continues when you Step inside to Updated flooring, paint and custom trim work that adds to the charm. Updated Electrical, Spacious Living room and dining room, wonderful Kitchen with plenty of Natural light with upgraded stainless steel appliances and great access to your side deck for those family Cookouts. You will LOVE the large laundry room with plenty of cabinets. Spacious bedrooms and closet space. DO NOT forget Oversized Workshop Garage, the Private, fully fenced backyard and firepit for the fall evenings. Cheap property taxes, Walking distance to downtown Arcadia or take a Golf Cart Cruise at night as Arcadia is Golf Cart Friendly. Enjoy Remnant Coffee Shop and the Farmers Market on Thursday evenings. CUTE CUTE CUTE.

504 E Broadway Avenue, Arcadia

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: EPYK Realty LLC.

$365,000
4 Beds 2 Baths
This charming home nestled in a friendly lakeside town offers the perfect blend of classic charm and modern updates. As you step into this delightful abode, you'll be greeted by a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The main floor features a spacious owner's suite, providing convenience and comfort. With four bedrooms and two full remodeled baths, there's plenty of room for the whole family or guests. Prepare to be amazed by the recent upgrades throughout the home. New windows, floors, furnace, and A/C ensure optimal comfort and energy efficiency all year round. You'll also appreciate the new water heater and Bluetooth water softener, adding convenience to everyday living. Entertain guests or simply unwind in the gorgeous backyard, complete with a large wooden deck perfect for hosting barbecues or enjoying quiet evenings under the stars. The strawberry and rhubarb garden adds a touch of nature's bounty to your outdoor oasis. Relax on the cute covered front porch and take in the picturesque landscaping that surrounds the home. With meticulous attention to detail, the landscaping enhances the curb appeal and creates a welcoming atmosphere. Location couldn't be better! Situated just steps away from Morse Reservoir, parks, and Jackson Street filled with restaurants and shops, you'll have everything you need right at your fingertips. Plus, being on the parade route for all holiday parades means you'll have front-row seats to the festivities. Embrace the laid-back lifestyle of this lakeside town, where golf carts are a common mode of transportation. Ditch your car and explore the area on a golf cart or enjoy a leisurely stroll to nearby attractions. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this exceptional home yours.

349 Washington Avenue, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Circle Real Estate.

$270,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to this well-maintained ranch-style home featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a classic brick and vinyl exterior, offering both durability and timeless appeal. Enjoy the fresh look of new LVP flooring throughout the kitchen, dining room, and great room, installed in 2024. The kitchen boasts newly added stainless steel appliances (September 2024), freshly painted white cabinets (September 2024), and a pantry for ample storage. The vaulted ceiling adds an open, airy feel. The dining room also features vaulted ceilings, enhancing the sense of space and light throughout the home. Three spacious bedrooms and two well-appointed bathrooms ensure plenty of room for everyone. Conveniently located close to Morse Reservoir and downtown Cicero, you'll enjoy easy access to local amenities, recreation, and dining. Seller is willing to negotiate buyer concessions.

1149 Frogs Leap, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N. Selling Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®.

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative