Top Realtor in Cicero, IN
Jason Kraus and the MOVE Group at REMAX Advanced Realty are Cicero, Indiana's dedicated local real estate specialists — a small-town, lake-community market with its own pricing patterns, school zoning, and waterfront rules that a generalist agent from outside Hamilton County can easily get wrong. As of August 2026, Cicero homes have a median sale price of $429,716, sell in a median of 22 days, and go for 98% of list price on average, with 15.6% of homes selling above asking — numbers that call for an agent who prices and negotiates with current data, not last year's comps.
Cicero's Real Estate Market in 2026
Cicero is a small, tight-knit Hamilton County town of about 5,655 residents, up 6.38% since the 2020 census, built around Morse Reservoir. Zillow's Home Value Index puts the typical Cicero home at $415,272, up 3.0% over the past year. Redfin rates Cicero a "very competitive" market with a Compete Score of 77 out of 100 — well-priced homes, especially those near the water, routinely draw multiple offers and close in a matter of days. That combination of a small listing inventory and steady buyer demand means both pricing strategy and marketing reach matter more here than in a larger, more liquid market.
Life on Morse Reservoir: Cicero's Defining Feature
What sets Cicero apart from every other Hamilton County town is Morse Reservoir itself — a 1,500-acre lake with about 35 miles of shoreline, built by the former Indianapolis Water Company (now Citizens Energy Group) and dedicated in 1956, bordered by Cicero to the north and Noblesville to the south. Waterfront and water-access properties here carry a real premium and a different due-diligence checklist than an inland home — dock rights, shoreline easements, and Citizens Energy's lake-level management all factor into value. The town's own Red Bridge Park and Marina sits right on the reservoir with a 60-slip marina (April–October season, seasonal waiting list), a fishing pier, kayak launch, and a rentable community building — a real amenity for buyers who want lake access without needing waterfront frontage themselves. An agent who can tell you which coves hold value and which lots come with lake-access headaches is worth more here than almost anywhere else in the county.
Hamilton Heights Schools and Family Life in Cicero
Cicero is zoned to Hamilton Heights School Corporation, based just north in Arcadia — Hamilton Heights Elementary, Middle, and High School all sit on St. Rd. 19. Niche gives the district an overall B+ grade and ranks it #74 of 291 school districts statewide, with a 95% graduation rate, an average SAT score of 1160, and a 16:1 student-teacher ratio. Niche also rates Cicero itself B+ overall, with an A- for crime and safety and a B+ for "good for families" — a smaller, quieter alternative to Westfield or Carmel for buyers who want Hamilton County schools and a rural, lake-town feel rather than a denser suburban one.
Choosing the Right Realtor for a Small Market
In a town Cicero's size, listing inventory is thin and word travels fast — pricing a home even slightly wrong, or marketing it only to the same local pool of buyers, costs sellers real money and time. Jason Kraus leads the MOVE Group at REMAX Advanced Realty, Hamilton County's dedicated local real estate specialists headquartered in Westfield, serving Westfield, Carmel, Noblesville, Cicero, and the surrounding communities since 2008. Jason is also Broker/Owner of REMAX Advanced Realty and team leader of the Indy Home Pros Team, REMAX's #1 team in Indiana by transactions — before real estate, he spent 12 years as a middle school English teacher, a background that shows in how clearly and patiently he communicates through a transaction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the top-rated realtor in Cicero, IN?
Jason Kraus, Broker/Owner of REMAX Advanced Realty and leader of the MOVE Group and the Indy Home Pros Team — REMAX's #1 team in Indiana by transactions — is a top-rated choice for buyers and sellers in Cicero, with deep knowledge of the Morse Reservoir waterfront market and Hamilton Heights school zoning.
What is the average home price in Cicero, Indiana?
As of August 2026, Redfin puts Cicero's median sale price at $429,716, and Zillow's Home Value Index lists the typical home value at $415,272, up 3.0% year-over-year.
Are Cicero homes zoned to Hamilton Heights schools?
Yes. Cicero is served by Hamilton Heights School Corporation, with its elementary, middle, and high schools all located on St. Rd. 19 in nearby Arcadia. Niche rates the district B+ overall, ranking it #74 of 291 Indiana school districts.
What makes Cicero different from Westfield, Carmel, or Noblesville?
Cicero is smaller and more rural in character, centered on the 1,500-acre Morse Reservoir. Buyers come here specifically for lake access, boating, and a quieter small-town feel, while still commuting into the Westfield/Carmel/Noblesville job and shopping corridors.
Is Cicero a good market for sellers right now?
Yes — Redfin rates Cicero "very competitive" (Compete Score 77/100) with a 22-day median time on market and 98% average sale-to-list ratio as of August 2026, meaning well-priced homes are moving quickly.
Explore more of Hamilton County real estate on our Hamilton County, IN Real Estate hub. Selling nearby? See our guides to Sell My Home in Noblesville, IN and Top Realtor in Noblesville, IN — Noblesville borders Morse Reservoir's south shore. Buying instead? Our Buyer's Agent in Noblesville, IN guide covers the same lake-adjacent market from the buy side. And see our companion guide, Sell My Home in Cicero, IN, for what selling a Cicero home actually involves.
Thinking about buying or selling on Morse Reservoir or anywhere in Cicero? Contact Jason Kraus and the MOVE Group at REMAX Advanced Realty for a no-pressure conversation about your Cicero real estate goals.
Buying instead of selling? See our Buyer's Agent in Cicero, IN guide for what representation looks like on the purchase side of a Cicero transaction.