Shelby County, IN Real Estate Search

Shelby County, IN Recently Sold Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for recently sold homes in Shelby County, IN and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Shelby County, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Shelby County, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Shelby County, IN Recently Sold Homes

$670,000
3 Beds 3 Baths
Priced below pre-list appraisal! Your dreams of rural living are ready to come true! Situated on 9 acres with Sugar Creek on site, you'll enjoy scenic views of wooded terrain and visiting wildlife. This beautiful property has been lovingly maintained by the same owner for 26 years. This home features 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms, Den and spacious living for your family with generously sized rooms to provide a comfortable and open living environment. Large kitchen with center island for easy entertaining with ample counter/cabinet space, large eat in kitchen area, and walk in pantry. The 9 Acre lot has plenty of space for outdoor activities. A 40x60 pole Barn is perfect for storage, workshops, or hobbyists. This home also has an 18x28 seperate jacuzzi room right off the lower back deck which includes an 8x8 jacuzzi with plenty of space for a bar and the outdoor paver patio has room for furniture with a firepit. The 2 level deck on the back of the home offers plenty of space for grilling and sitting around to enjoy friends/family. Sit out front and enjoy the koi ponds and waterfall. The open back acreage leads to a wooded area that spans the width of the property. During the warmer months, enjoy the above ground Kayak saltwater pool (practically maintenance free). This property offers the perfect blend of rural charm and modern amenities. If you're looking for a peaceful retreat and a place to create lasting memories with your family, this home has it all. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity to own in sought after rural Shelby County. 5 minutes from New Palestine, which offers out of district registration (packet attached). New Pal schools are closer than assigned Triton schools. 20-25 min from the city and Greenwood. Schedule a viewing today! See attachments for items that convey with property, that are for sale/negotiable with strong offer, and recent upgrades/improvements. Pre-list inspection done, items repaired

11335 N 600 W, Fountaintown

Listing courtesy of Crossroads Real Estate Group LLC. Selling Office: EZRE.

$225,000
5 Beds 1 Baths
**BUYER DIDN'T CLOSE*FHA APPRAISAL READY**Charming Victorian Gem in Historic Fairland!** Discover the perfect blend of history and convenience in this lovingly maintained Victorian-era home, built in 1877. Located in the heart of the vibrant rural community of Fairland, this 5-bedroom residence offers the quintessential small-town experience with modern amenities. **Prime Location & Community Highlights:** Nestled in a peaceful and welcoming rural town, you'll enjoy easy access to local retail shops, restaurants, churches, and an active public park. The home is just a 5-minute commute to the nearby casino and I-74, providing quick and convenient travel options. **Historic Charm & Modern Comforts:** This stunning home has been lovingly cared for by the same family for 60 years, preserving its rich character. The main level boasts an inviting eat-in kitchen complete with appliances, a cozy gas log fireplace warming the formal living and dining rooms, and period built-ins, including a formal dining room china cabinet. The versatile second bedroom features built-in bookshelves and a spacious walk-in closet. **Endless Possibilities:** A charming upper-level bonus room offers additional flexible space, perfect for creating a second bathroom or customizing to suit your lifestyle. The home features oak hardwood floors under the main level carpet and offers a delightful wraparound porch plus a separate covered side porch, providing plenty of outdoor relaxation spaces. **Outdoor Sanctuary:** Situated on a generous .44-acre double lot, the property features a park-like fenced yard, a picnic area, a storage shed, and a 3-car detached garage with loft storage, plus ample street parking. With a spacious 2,298 square feet of living space, this home offers plenty of room for storage and creative possibilities. **Make It Your Own:** This comfortable and inviting home is ready for your personal touch. The possibilities are endless!

302 W Washington Street, Fairland

Listing courtesy of My Agent. Selling Office: Your Realty Link, LLC.

$90,000
2 Beds 1 Baths
Experience Timeless Charm! This inviting home is a true reflection of quality craftsmanship and lasting appeal. Lovingly cared for by the same owners since 1978, this 1900-built house is ready for you to uncover its classic character. Step into 1,264 square feet of history, where vintage details abound. From the original hardwoods under the carpet to the classic doors, hardware, and large moldings, this home boasts tall ceilings and an undeniable sense of warmth, waiting to continue its story. The roomy front living area and cozy sitting space are perfect for relaxing or spending time with friends and family. Just off the kitchen, the dining room retains its original light fixtures, adding to the home's nostalgic feel. The well-kept kitchen offers a balance of vintage charm with plenty of room for updates to suit your style. With two spacious bedrooms, one bathroom, a practical mudroom, and plenty of storage, this home blends comfort and convenience. Outside, you'll find an oversized one-car garage and an additional lot that brings the total property size to .30 acres. Whether you need space for storage, a workshop, or want to start a garden under the shade of the mature sugar maple trees, this outdoor space offers endless possibilities. Located just a few miles from Morristown and within 20 minutes of Shelbyville, Greenfield, or New Palestine, this charming piece of Gwynneville history provides both a welcoming community and easy access to nearby towns. A great opportunity to own a piece of the past, this home is priced affordably and sold "as is." Recent updates include a serviced furnace, a new sump pump, and new porch steps. Don't miss out on making this delightful home yours!

7111 E Us Highway 52, Gwynneville

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$305,000
2 Beds 2 Baths
Nested in one of the most desirable neighborhoods, this immaculate 2 bedroom retreat sitting on an expansive 0.5 Acre Lot exudes charm and sophistication and offers the perfect blend of tranquility and modern convenience. This property has been lovingly cared for, featuring pristine interiors with natural light pouring into each room, accentuating the open and airy layout. The spacious living areas flow seamlessly into a thoughtfully designed kitchen, perfect for both casual meals and entertaining. Both bedrooms are generously sized with ample closet space, and both of the bathrooms feature new cabinets lighting and tub/shower fixtures with solid surface counters and new fixtures. The most recent updates include: Adding 200 sq. to the house by converting the old 3 season room into a family room (Insulation of new addition with new windows insulation and entry door. 20K. ) New Bryant heating and AC in 2022.8K. Remodeling of kitchen. New Granite counter tops new cabinets. New dishwasher also installed with garbage disposal. 18K. Install new bathroom . 7K New vinyl plank flooring and carpet. 10K. Custom window blinds that will stay with the house. 3K. New detached garage. Totally insulated and finished on inside. 40K. Installed belt driven garage door opener in attached garage with outside keypads. 3K New side walk to detached garage 2k. Installed stone in back sitting area and created fire pit area will stay with the house New gas log with remote 2k. Outside, the expansive yard invites endless possibilities, whether you envision enjoying the serenity of mature trees and open green space or entertaining parties year round the choice is yours.

1000 Spring Hill Road, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Runnebohm Realty, LLC. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker/Sirkus-Allen.

$405,000
4 Beds 3 Baths
Discover country living at its finest with this charming 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house nestled on a picturesque plot of land. Boasting a spacious 2-car attached garage, this home offers both convenience and functionality. Step inside to find a newly updated kitchen, complete with sleek granite countertops, perfect for culinary enthusiasts and entertainers alike. The open layout seamlessly flows into the dining area, making family meals and gatherings a joy. Relax and unwind in the comfort of the cozy living room, ideal for quiet evenings or hosting guests. With four bedrooms, there's ample space for a growing family or accommodating visitors. But the allure doesn't end there. Venture outside to discover a newly constructed deck, offering the perfect spot for enjoying morning coffee or evening sunsets. For those with furry or feathered friends, the fenced-in area provides a safe haven for animals to roam and play. And for those with hobbies or in need of extra storage, the barn offers endless possibilities. A bonus room that's more than just extra space; it's a sanctuary tailored to your desires. The attic offers a hidden treasure trove of storage possibilities, allowing you to declutter your living spaces and keep your belongings organized with ease. Whatever your passion, this bonus room promises to be the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories. Make it your own and elevate your lifestyle with this unparalleled addition to your new home. Experience the serenity of country living while still being just a short drive from city amenities. Start envisioning a life filled with the sweet rewards of your very own fruit trees, the property offers peach and honeycrisp apple trees. Don't miss your chance to make this dream property your own. Schedule a showing today!

4030 S 250 E, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass. Selling Office: Weichert, REALTORSĀ®.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative