Cicero, IN Real Estate | Cicero, IN Recently Sold Homes

This beautiful 3 bed, 2 bath home sits in the heart of Cicero! Less than 2.5 miles from Morse Reservoir, but close enough to hear the boats and jet skis! Spend your evenings on the amazing back deck enjoying nature, around the firepit, entertaining, or navigating the walking trails galore! Stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, updated hardwood flooring, and the list goes on! Other updates include : Refrigerator (2023), Dishwasher (2023), Master bedroom closet shelving (2022), and a new fold away ladder for the attic. Community is golf-cart friendly.

3038 Stilton Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Hardie Group. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$305,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Nestled in a tranquil, Cicero, this captivating 2,644-square-foot abode exudes charm. With three spacious bedrooms and a dedicated office space, this house effortlessly balances comfort and functionality. Step inside, and you'll find a breakfast room bathed in warm, golden sunlight, the perfect place to savor your morning coffee. For those seeking elegance, the dining room awaits with its shimmering chandelier and an inviting ambiance, setting the stage for unforgettable gatherings. As you step into the backyard, a privacy fence surrounds the lush garden, offering a secluded oasis for relaxation and outdoor activities. But the true gem of this dwelling is its location-a mere stroll away from the embrace of the local park, ensuring your days are filled with nature's beauty and tranquil moments. This house is not just a home; it's an enchanting retreat where modern comfort harmonizes with the serenity of a quiet neighborhood.

1149 Oak Hill Lane, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

LOCATION LOCATION!! Just a stones throw away from Morse Lake! Cute Ranch with Tons of charm, Situated on a Huge Lot that is over 0.36 of an acre, Mature Trees and fenced backyard. Spacious 3 Beds, 2 Bath, Great room with Vaulted Ceilings, Lovely Kitchen and Breakfast area. Do Not forget the additional Family room or could be 4th Bedroom or Home Office. Primary Bedroom offers a private On-suite Bathroom. Oversized 2 Car Garage with extra Storage and Workshop space. Large Laundry Room. You will LOVE the Location and all the Cicero Amenities and events. Jump right on the Cicero Walking Path or enjoy Cicero Community Park and Pickleball. Easy Walk to Downtown Cicero or Cruise around town on a Golf Cart. This one is a cutie.

1160 Stringtown Pike, Cicero

Listing courtesy of MIBOR REALTOR® Association. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$499,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Location!! Just a short walk to Morse Lake! Rare Find in Cicero! Check out this AMAZING Ranch home with a Full Finished WALK-OUT Basement!! This home offers so much Flex space with 4-Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Home Office Space, Situated on a Private Wooded Lot with Covered Back Porch. You will love this OPEN floorplan with huge Great room with Vaulted Ceilings, Large Dining Room, Awesome Kitchen with Center islands, Lots of Cabinets, Walk-in Pantry, Breakfast Bar and Eat in Kitchen Area. Gorgeous Primary Bedroom Suite with Amazing Windows overlooking the backyard and a private door to the back deck. Main Floor Office/Den could also be used for that additional bedroom on the main floor. 2nd and 3rd Bedrooms on Main offers a Jack and Jill bath. Large Main Flr laundry room. Do NOT forget about the Amazing Space in the Walk-out Basement that offers a Huge Family Family Room with Fireplace, Wet Bar, Theater Room, Work out Room, Bedroom with Egress Windows, FULL Bath and connects to the additional Garage Bay for Mower/Golf Cart. All New Paint in Some bedrooms, New Paint and Carpet in Basement. This home is Close to Downtown Cicero with Quaint Shops and Restaurants and close to Red Bridge Park and Morse Lake that offers Kayak Launch, FISHING Boat Launch, Fishing Pier. Boat Dock Rental possible at Red Bridge Park BUT will be on a waiting list! This home has SO much to offer.

2040 W Morse Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: Ferris Property Group.

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Downtown Cicero Gem! Discover the epitome of comfortable living in this spacious 3-bedroom, 2-full bathroom nestled in the heart of downtown Cicero. Promising a lifestyle of convenience and leisure, this home is perfectly situated within walking distance to the picturesque Morse Lake. Step inside to find a tastefully updated interior that offers nothing but charm and a mix between the old and new. The home's layout extends outdoors, where a garden paradise awaits. Imagine spending evenings unwinding in the beauty of your own private oasis. The expansive large homesite provides endless possibilities for outdoor recreation and gardening. Recent upgrades, including a newer roof, siding, windows, doors, gutters with guards which will be sure to give you peace of mind and low-maintenance living for years to come. The convenience of having ample parking space adds to the property's uniqueness allowing you and your guests to come and go with ease and plenty of room for boats, jet ski's or even a large 3-4 car garage if needed. Location couldn't be more prime - surrounded by the vibrant energy of downtown Cicero. Walk to local favorites such as the renowned Boathouse Kitchen offering lakeside dining, 10 West, Pizza King, Big Dawgs BBQ and around so many more. Every day presents an opportunity to explore charming boutiques, cozy cafes, and community events that this charming town is known for. Whether you seek a full-time residence or a weekend retreat, this downtown Cicero gem caters to your desires. Immerse yourself close to the lakeside lifestyle and seize the chance to own a piece of this thriving community.

270 E Jackson Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$263,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

ONE BLOCK FROM MORSE RESERVOIR! This shotgun style ranch on over 1/2 acre is waiting for you to move in and enjoy growing downtown Cicero, open floor plan and convenience of the primary bedroom suite on the main floor! Home was recently remodeled with beautiful kitchen cabinets, leathered granite counter tops, canned lighting, and open floor plan, to name a few! Primary bedroom is spacious with a suite with double sinks and large walk-in closet. Luxury vinyl plank floors throughout main floor. You will love the large, fenced in (6' chain link) yard to watch fireworks from and your covered front porch to watch the parade from!!

150 Washington Avenue, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Traditions Realty, LLC. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$110,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome Home, Your Lakeside Cottage, Getaway awaits. This would be a great weekend place with just a stones throw to the lake and all the great Amenities Cicero has to offer. Golf Cart Friendly Community, Walking Distance to Kayak Launch, Park & Downtown Cicero. Quiet Cul-de-sac lot that offers the sights & sounds of Morse Lake. Private Fenced yard, HUGE Barn that offers plenty of storage and enough space for a workshop or your Golf Cart. Lovely enclosed Sunroom/Lanai for those cool evenings, Step inside to a well maintained home w/Open Living Rm and Dining room, Large Kitchen with Breakfast Bar. All kitchen appliances included plus washer/dryer. Lot is owned with property. NO Lot Rent. Possible Boat Dock rentals avail at Red Bridge Park.

94 Rosewood Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: eXp Realty, LLC.

$629,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome Home! Wow! GORGEOUS Custom Home in the Desirable Neighborhood of Deer Walk Estates in Cicero! Very Well Maintained Country Home but close to Everything. Close to Morse Lake and easy access to SR 37 and SR 19. Situated On a Peaceful Wooded Lot, on Over 1.07 Acres with NO HOA! Nearly 5,000 Square feet, 4 Beds and 3 Full Baths, You will LOVE this sprawling ALL BRICK Ranch with a Full Walk-Out Basement and Oversized 3 Car Garage with a back staircase to basement! Step inside to a Bright and Open Floorplan that feels like NEW. Amazing Great Room with Custom Built-ins, Lovely Gas Fireplace for those Winter Evenings and Views of this BEAUTIFUL backyard. Large Open Kitchen with New Stainless Refrigerator, Dishwasher and Microwave. Large Breakfast Room with backyard views! This home offers plenty of FLEX Space with a Main Floor Office that could be a Formal Dining room, Spacious Mudroom off Garage, Large Laundry and Walk-in Pantry! Spacious Bedrooms with Walk-in closets, HUGE Primary Bedroom with a SPA Like Bath! You will be amazed of all the Extra Space the Basement has to offer, Plumbed for Bath and ready to be Finished! Relax on your Covered Back Porch for your morning coffee or evening night cap. Plenty of room for your Camper or Boat! You will LOVE this Location!!

11920 Deer Walk Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: RE/MAX Edge.

$780,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to your dream home! This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom ranch-style residence is nestled on a 1.13-acre wooded lot in exclusive Forest Bay with no HOA, offering a perfect blend of comfort and luxury. The expansive 1.13-acre wooded lot features two peaceful creeks, a tranquil koi pond, and ample space for play and exploration. The deeded Morse Reservoir access, which includes a boat dock, boat ramp, and beach access, ensures you'll enjoy all the benefits of lake living and water-based recreation.The three-car garage provides ample space for your vehicles and storage needs, as well as electric vehicle charging capability.The main level of the home boasts a recently updated gourmet kitchen that will delight any chef, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, suede finish granite countertops, coffee bar and a spacious island. All-new flooring throughout the main level enhances the overall aesthetic, ensuring a welcoming ambiance. The 4-bedrooms ensure everyone has their own space, with the main floor primary bedroom suite serving as a tranquil retreat. The primary bathroom has been recently updated and features heated floors for your comfort. Step into the 3 seasons room and be captivated by serene views, providing an ideal spot for morning coffee or evening cocktails. The spacious composite deck is perfect for grilling and outdoor dining, while the hot tub offers year-round relaxation. The laundry room has been recently updated with folding shelves and drying racks, adding practicality to daily living. Mini Barn on property has pad for RV and 50 amp charging. In summary, this property is a rare gem offering a 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom ranch-style home with a three-car garage and remarkable outdoor amenities. The deeded Morse Reservoir access is a coveted feature that guarantees you'll experience all the advantages of lake living. Don't miss the chance to make this extraordinary property your forever home. It's a perfect blend of luxury, comfort and natural beauty!

100 Royal Pine Lane, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$285,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Charming 4 bedroom 2 bath home in Cicero! Blend of charm and modern updates in this move in ready home! Home features 10' ceilings, hardwood floors, cozy wood burning fireplace, claw foot tub, new vinyl plank floors upstairs and updated and spacious kitchen w/newer appliances. Newer vinyl windows, fresh paint (interior & exterior) and new insulation/attic fan! Large spacious and private back deck is completely fenced in PLUS fully fenced yard behind the 2 car garage! Walk to downtown Cicero to enjoy shopping, restaurants and Morse Lake!

410 S Peru Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$490,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Love the outdoors and gorgeous views? Kayaking? Fishing? Gardening?Enjoy nature every day on 2.5 acres bordered by woods & lush landscaping overlooking Cicero Creek. Incredible privacy in this updated tri-level with 3BD/2.5BA. GR & FR open to kitchen w/granite counters, upgraded appliances, & huge center island. Walk out from both rooms to an expansive backyard deck, a layout perfect for entertaining or quiet country nights. Primary BD w/en suite & large closet. Oversized garage. Fish off the deck of your Man-Cave or She-Shed complete w/electric. Large storage barn/workshop also has electric. Drive your golf cart to town or take your pontoon over to Morse Reservoir. Country living at it's best - a place to be home & make lifelong memories!

24598 Crooked Creek Road, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

$323,319

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

MI Home new build

642 Tamarack Larch Boulevard, Cicero

Listing courtesy of MIBOR REALTOR® Association. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$392,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

ATTENTION BUYERS: SELLER WILL OFFER A 2/1 BUY DOWN TO ANY PURCHASER AT LIST PRICE. START RATE TO BE 2% BELOW CURRENT 30 YEAR RATE. *THIS OFFER IS ONLY GOOD WITH BUYER USING TUCKER MORTGAGE* Absolutely immaculate, this gorgeous custom built, 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath, 2-story features beautiful, completely updated kitchen/breakfast room opening to airy family room w/fireplace, DR, LR/Den, lovely master suite and 3 additional bedrooms up. Updates include, LVT flooring, Updates all baths, HVAC, front door, paint and much more. All of this situated on lovely well-landscaped lot with fully fenced back yard and large patio in desirable Morse Landing. Convenient to lake, parks and schools. Just buy and relax!

935 Morse Landing Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$40,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Great investment opportunity. This home is within walking distance to Morse Reservoir and downtown Cicero. You could live or own a rental in the lakeside community that offers a wonderful lifestyle. With a little bit of work this home could be in livable condition. Nice lot that backs up to a wooded area.

18 Morse Court, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

$580,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

WOW! Morse Lake WATERFRONT home in Cicero! It will feel like a Vacation while relaxing in this Fabulous Entertainment Space w/Outdoor Kitchen, Water Fall features & your OWN Covered Boat Dock & Jet Ski Docks. Peaceful Cul-De-Sac Lot w/ Mature Trees & being dredged in 2024 for additional Water Depth! Wonderful Curb Appeal w/Soaring Windows Across the Front. Step Inside to a Vaulted Great Rm that is Open to your Brkfast Area, Lovely Kitchen & Huge Sunroom. Main Flr Primary bedrm that offers private doors w/Views of the Lake & a hot tub area. Main Flr Bath w/new walk-in shower! Spacious Bedrms Upstairs w/Views of the Water & Updated bathm. Finished Basement for that EXTRA space you need w/Family Rm, Game Rm, Office/Storage, half bath & MORE!!

230 Bayshore Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$609,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

WOW! Beautiful UPDATED County Ranch Home situated on 5 acres! Are you Ready to look up at the Stars at night and feel that Country Breeze...This is it!! Well Appointed, Remodeled Home w/SO much to Love! This is the Country Home you have always wanted BUT still close to town & MORSE LAKE! Only 10 mins to Lake Fishing, Kayak Launch & Boating. Plenty of Land to build your DREAM Barn & a Mini Farm. Plenty of Garage/Workshop Space, Many Fruit Trees, Wildflowers, New James Hardie Siding & Cedar accents, New Triple pane Windows, New Flooring thru-out, Updated Open Flrplan, New Wood Stove, Updated Baths & Kitchen, New Appliances & New Open Brkfast bar. New HVAC & Ductwrk, H20 Heater, Roof, Gutters, Soffits, Pressure tank, Insulation & MUCH MORE.

25710 Overdorf Road, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$345,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome home to this newly-built 2br/2ba paired villa ranch home in the desirable Tamarack neighborhood in beautiful Cicero! This is low maintenance living at its finest. Lawncare, snow removal, and exterior maintenance is taken care for you. This home features open concept living, a split bedroom floorplan, an oversized primary bedroom featuring an en-suite bathroom, spacious walk-in closet and a door leading you straight to the laundry room. Talk about convenient! Enjoy your mornings on the covered front porch and sunsets on the private rear veranda overlooking a fully fenced in backyard. Whether you enjoy family time at the local parks, spending the day on Morse Reservoir, or exploring local restaurants, you're sure to love living here!

107 Hovden Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. Selling Office: MIBOR REALTOR® Association.

$399,900

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to Auburn Estates! This 1 year old home is Lennar's Valencia floorplan. A perfect blend of modern comfort, classic charm + a warm neutral color palette in the heart of Cicero! The main lvl features a bdrm w/full bath great for guests, formal dining room, Great Rm, Eat in Kit w/quartz tops, SS appliances, lots of storage & lrg center island, mudroom area w/bltins off garage + 1/2 bath. 4 Bedrms, Loft, & upstairs laundry close to bedrooms. Primary bath w/dbl sinks, w/i shower & w/i closet. Enjoy serene views on newly stamped concrete patio or take a quick ride to downtown Cicero, a local park or Morse Reservoir. Fiber internet available, new ceiling fans thruout, new water softner stays + transferable 9 Yr Builders Warranty!

16 Hollister Way, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home. Selling Office: Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$675,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Completely updated ranch WATERFRONT home. Walk out to your private pier with a perfect location for sunset views on the main body of Morse. Spacious open layout with 4 Bds 3 Baths. Great for entertaining lots of guests! Plenty of parking with 2 driveways and 2 sets of washer and dryer hookups! Everything designed with low maintenance lake lifestyle in mind, vinyl plank flooring/quartz counter tops. All baths are updated and master is something you must see to appreciate!

1180 Bayswater Lane, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Rhino Realty LLC. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$850,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Seeking the tranquility of nature? This magnificent 5 bedroom home sits on one of the most unique rolling 10 acre landscapes in Indiana. A winding creek, deep valleys, cliffs and mature hardwood forest are not terms typically used for residential properties here but this home has all of them. Truly a nature lovers paradise! Situated in the middle of this ideal setting, this updated home continues the enchantment as you step inside to its majestic beamed ceilings, massive stone fireplace and rich hardwoods throughout. Bonuses include outbuilding featuring additional 2 car garage, complete in law quarters, workshop and heated in ground pool. All of this w/quick access to 31 and just minutes from Morse Reservoir! https://youtu.be/37lWx-gIcHE

2646 E 236th Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$230,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

290 N Peru Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of MIBOR REALTOR® Association. Selling Office: RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

$181,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Looking for acreage in the country with peaceful rural setting, yet close to town, easy for commuting needs and Hamilton Heights school district? This 1.3 acre property is located at the corner of 256th st and SR 213 and has tons of potential. IF your looking for a location that can provide multi generational living consider this one! This parcel has the ability to have 2 residential structures on it but can not be split. The property has 2 residential structures currently, 1 shared well and 2 septic systems. So many possibilities; single family living; multi generational or investment.

12742 E 256th Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: Inspire Real Estate LLC.

$940,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Experience lakeside living at its finest! A remarkable lake home with a modern feel, offering a picturesque retreat with some of the best views of the lake! Featuring 2 docks, multiple boat bays, boat lift with canopy, $20k worth of recent concrete patio & steps with lighting. Providing easy access to endless water activities. The open great room boasts vaulted ceilings with a light-airy ambiance, while the tall fireplace, newer laminate flooring throughout the main & upper levels, freshly painted window trim & numerous kitchen updates add touches of modern elegance. The walkout basement provides versatility perfect for entertainment or a quiet retreat.

710 Pleasant Point Circle, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker - Kaiser. Selling Office: Compass Indiana, LLC.

$258,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Location!! Charming Ranch close to MORSE LAKE. Welcome Home to the Amazing Lakeside Town of Cicero Indiana. Great Location to Cicero Community Park, Pickleball, Golf Cart Friendly Town with Awesome shopping, Restaurants and Lake Activities. You will LOVE the Spacious, Open Flrplan with Vaulted Great room, Split Bedroom Flrplan, Large Kitchen w/stainless steel appliances, Breakfast Area and Breakfast Bar. Large Primary Bedrm with Walk-in closet and Luxury Spa bath. Relax on the Large Patio, Private Fenced in Backyard. Oversized 2 Car garage with extension for bikes, lawnmower and trashcans. This one is charming and quick possession.

1069 Oak Hill Lane, Cicero

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: RE/MAX Complete.

$260,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

3 bedroom 2 bath ranch in Cicero. Enjoy the welcoming front porch and open floor plan with vaulted ceilings. Spacious kitchen with dining area and plenty of counter space. Split floor plan with primary BR on one side and 2 BR on the other. Primary BR with huge walk-in closet. Private backyard with no neighbors behind. Walking distance to Morse Reservoir.

2043 Treving Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Roofstock Realty, LLC. Selling Office: Trueblood Real Estate.

$389,750

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 122 Ardglass Street in Cicero, featuring a beautiful new 2,620 square foot home! Inside, a spacious study with 2 doors awaits, along with the steps leading up to the second floor. The long foyer hall guides you past a half bathroom and into the gathering room, dining nook, and kitchen trio! For an extra special touch, there is an added a box bay window to the dining nook, complete with sliding glass doors to your backyard. Upstairs, your laundry room sits right at the top next to the light-filled loft and across the hall from the luxurious owner's suite. The other 3 bedrooms are tucked off another hallway on the second floor.

122 Ardglass Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of M/I Homes of Indiana, L.P.. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$399,990

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 127 Ardglass Street where you will fall in love with its 2,447 square feet, 4 bedrooms, and 2.5 bathrooms. The covered porch welcomes you inside this home's generous foyer where you will find a flex room upon entry. Follow the main hallway past the staircase and the half bathroom to be greeted by a fantastic open-concept living area that contains a kitchen with a large pantry, a family room, and a dining nook with sliding doors to the backyard. Venture upstairs to discover a laundry closet, 3 sizable secondary bedrooms, and a full bath. Your delightful owner's suite completes the second floor and provides you with a spacious bedroom, a walk-in closet, and an en-suite bath.

127 Ardglass Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of M/I Homes of Indiana, L.P.. Selling Office: MIBOR REALTOR® Association.

Cicero, IN Recently Sold Homes

Newest Cicero, IN Recently Sold Homes

MOVE Group

Search

Resources

About