Shelby County, IN Real Estate Search

Shelby County, IN Recently Sold Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for recently sold homes in Shelby County, IN and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Shelby County, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Shelby County, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Shelby County, IN Recently Sold Homes

$334,950
3 Beds 3 Baths
Are you ready to own a very unique property that every sq inch has been exceptionally finished? You are instantly welcomed by this urban oasis nestled in the heart of Shelbyville when you step into the federal design historic building. The living space is a cross between a gorgeous urban oasis and industrial feel with incredible warmth. This impressive residence has been used as a mixed use property for many years and was most recently used as a 2 tenant loft style property. Here are just some of the finishing touches in this home: High Ceilings, custom doors and tall custom windows, exposed brick and beams (the first floor is 4 bricks deep and 2nd floor is 3!) dimensional roof, beautiful hardwood floors, custom lighting, attractive modern kitchen and baths, spray foam insulated attic and so much more. Everything in this home has been custom created down to the window coverings. The main floor has a great room with dining space, built in wall book shelf, a luxury kitchen, a pantry that any chef would envy, office and a half bath. Upstairs you will find the primary suite with walk in closet, 2nd bedroom and the 3rd bedroom is 16x18 and is being used as a sitting room/guest space, another full bath and laundry. For parking the home has a driveway and parking space in in the back. This space could be converted into a private yard, but if grassy outdoor space is a must, this home is conveniently located by Kennedy Park! Enjoy the festivals, downtown entertainment, retail shops, post office, restaurants all within walking distance. There will be an album in the home to see some of history and a look at the remodel as it took place. This one is not a 10, but beyond! The property is now back on the market at no fault of the sellers as buyers financing fell through right before closing. The property is now zone residential and has an fha appraisal on file.

428 E Washington Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Hoosier, REALTORS®. Selling Office: Hoosier, REALTORS®.

$189,900
3 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to this beautiful 1,896 sqft home in Shelbyville, featuring 3 beds and 2 brand new full bathrooms. Large covered porch, a perfect space for greeting guests out of the weather. Spacious living room bathed with new recessed lighting, ceiling fan, and hardwood floors. The dining room, which can also serve as an office with recessed lights, prewired for a fan, and matching hardwood floors. The kitchen with ample cabinet storage, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, prewired for a fan, and hardwood floors. The main-level primary bedroom offers raised ceilings. The all-new main-level bathroom features a step-in shower, tiled floors, and an open vanity. Upstairs, discover a cozy desk nook, a large dormer closet, and two bedrooms separated by a brand new full bathroom with a shower/tub combo and tile floors. The laundry room, equipped with vinyl plank floors, provides access to an unfinished cellar. This home boasts all-new plumbing and electrical systems, ensuring peace of mind. Outside, enjoy a cozy deck area, a large paver patio, a mini barn for extra storage, and a fire pit. The gravel parking area at the rear of the property offers space for three cars. This home combines modern amenities with classic charm, making it the perfect place to call home. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity!

512 S Pike Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Weichert, Realtors-Tralee Prop. Selling Office: MIBOR REALTOR® Association.

$420,000
3 Beds 3 Baths
Hard to find over 6 very useable acres and a roomy, updated comfortable Ranch style house with large finished basement in the very desirable Triton Central district. The covered front porch and multi-level back decks to watch the sun set, enjoy the firefies, see the occasional deer wander through your back acres, or entertain if you feel so inclined. Inside, you will find special touches throughout the house. The fully remodeled kitchen opens into the dining area, flowing seamlessly to the upstairs living room. Just off the kitchen is the laundry/utility room which also has a large pantry. there is a special water filter/conditioner dedicated to the washer there, although the current owners have not used it. There is new flooring throughout the house. The master bedroom down the hall on the main floor has a lovely view of the back acreage, and an in suite master bathroom featuring a separate shower, a whirlpool tub, double sinks, and a tall storage cabinet. It is also at the opposite end of the house from the other 2 bedrooms for a bit more privacy. The basement offers a 2 car attached garage, a really large family room with a huge storage space behind the new stylish doors, and two other versatile bonus rooms. Recently installed are new roof ( 1yr) , new siding, some new windows, new kitchen ( 6mo), new flooring throughout; new doors, new light fixtures, upgraded full bath in basement; SO much storage space, outside, too! A detached garage with dirt and stone floor was previously used for horse stables; a very large pole barn with dirt floor contains utility posts and fencing to put back up if someone wants horses or livestock, and MORE storage! The curving driveway to the house is the gateway to your new sanctuary!

5209 N Frontage Road, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Culmann Real Estate Group, LLC. Selling Office: F.C. Tucker Company.

$710,000
4 Beds 4 Baths
Want to be a Homesteader? Fabulous custom built Hearthstone log home on 12.03 acres with all the amentities you desire! Inground heated 8.5 ft deep pool, covered outdoor built-in kitchen, trails through the woods to Coffey Creek. 4 bedrooms & 4.5 baths plus a finished walk-out basement housing the entertainment & family rooms, (pool table incld), wet bar & laundry plus, elec. baseboard for back-up heat. Beautiful 116 ft stone wall with wood burning fireplace in living rm. 200 yr old yellow pine (not yellow in color) floors from Norfolk VA. Custom built doors & closets. 3-zone HVAC, Heat pump with LP back-up. Tennessee Flag Stone walkway leads to a large covered porch with swing. Master bath has large slate shower plus separate jet tub, 2 sink vanity, also a walk-in closet. 15 x 20 Master bedroom has sitting area, vaulted beamed ceiling & hardware for barn door. Flatrock Furniture master bed, bar stools and table stay as well as pool furniture. Seller is willing to leave "cabin" style furnishing. Sit in the screened-in deck off of kitchen to watch wildlife in their natural habitat or, walk to the stone firepit to roast marshmallows, get back in to nature! There is a detached 2/3 car garage with floored storage above. Plenty of cleared space for a garden or orchard. The property is located just a few miles from town, Shelbyville, within 10 min to interstate, grocery stores, restaurants and all city amenities. There's only been 3 families to own this home, you can be the 4th! Please try to give 24 hr notice to show. Do not drive down lane without an appointment.

2483 N 200 E, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®. Selling Office: C & S Real Estate, Inc..

$309,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Amazing brick ranch home with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, large kitchen, and 2 living spaces. The entire home has vinyl plank flooring. Large eat-in kitchen with tons of cabinet and counter space that overlooks the great room. This great room is where you will spend a lot of time. It features a very large footprint for entertaining and overlooks the spacious fenced in back yard. There is also a living room as you enter the front door that can be used for an additional seating/gathering area. Large covered front porch is a great place to sit after dinner or for some early morning coffee. You can also utilize the rear open patio that overlooks the large fenced in back yard for the same thing. The home features a 2 car attached garage and so much more. When you go outside, you can imagine games being played with enough room for football, baseball, or about any sport you want to play. The yard also features a large mini barn that can store your mower, or outdoor tools for your garden. Don't forget about the detached 2 car garage either. The detached garage has enough room to park 2 cars with tons of room to have a huge workshop. But wait, there is even more. The 2 car garage features an upstairs that could easily be converted into a home office space or even additional living area. It could serve as an in-law quarters or teen getaway if you wanted. Endless possibilities with this well cared for home. Tons of upgrades to include updated windows, roof, HVAC, and crawlspace encapsulation. Make an appointment and let your mind come up with all kinds of ideas about how you can use the space for your next home.

3385 S Shelby 750 W, Franklin

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC. Selling Office: REALTY WORLD-Harbert Company.

$550,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Your dreams of rural living in a charming chalet-style log home are ready to come true! Situated on 6 acres with Sugar Creek *on site,* you'll enjoy both scenic views of expansive fields AND wooded terrain with kayaking just outside your backdoor! An oversized front porch makes a great first impression and serves as a perfect outdoor living area. Inside you are amazed by 23-foot soaring ceilings with open, exposed framework. Imagine your favorite lodge - this is it! Open concept main living/dining/kitchen areas are perfect for large family gatherings. This home is incredible during the holidays (ah-hem... HUGE Christmas tree opportunity)! An impressive floor-to-ceiling masonry fireplace is the focal point and features a blower insert that can heat your whole home in the winter if you desire! Gourmet kitchen with a cooktop and separate ovens plus a pantry - not to mention an oversized overflow pantry around the corner. Incredible storage! The primary suite is split from the spare bedrooms and offers tall ceilings that carry throughout, an enormous walk in closet and full en-suite bath with linen storage. Spare bedrooms are generous in size and adjacent to an updated full bath. Last but not least your expansive sunroom makes for the perfect flex room - great for a home office/hobby room/playroom/home gym... endless possibilities. The sunroom opens onto the rear porch and is just steps away from the 2 car garage. This outbuilding not only serves as a garage but also has a separate bonus room currently being used as an office. Great way to keep home life and business life separate! The 2nd outbuilding is even larger with both workshop/garage space and the most amazing "man cave" space! Heated too!! Previous owners outfitted this building with a bathroom and a kitchenette! Perfect opportunity for a home-based business! Updates include new HVAC, almost all new windows and brand new metal roofing with a 50 year transferrable warranty!

11186 N 650 W, Fountaintown

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz. Selling Office: Hoosier, REALTORS®.

$295,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
The GREATEST value in all of Shelbyville and Shelby County!!! This home exemplifies pride of ownership and pride in craftsmanship. You have to see it with your own eyes to completely understand. It all starts with the hardy plank siding in the perfect shade of blue. Sprawling covered porch in the front and massive deck in the back for your outdoor living paradise. The windows speak for themselves with the highest quality product all while maintaining the original beautiful craftsmanship and abundance of natural light. The classic craftsman wood trim and wood doors still bless this property with copious character. The beautifully finished hard wood floors give the home the sturdy feel and look of a classic Victorian home. The spacious main level living room and formal dining room will fit the bill for all the biggest family gatherings. The updated kitchen is the perfect blend of modern meets Victorian with more than enough counter space for the largest meal preparations in addition to the kitchen island. The main level utility room is where you will find the laundry hook ups with built in shelves to keep every household well organized. The main level bathroom is simple yet elegant and the shower is richly tiled floor to ceiling. The upstairs bathroom is extremely large with a soaker jacuzzi tub. 3 Bedrooms upstairs where you will find a bedroom with a hand crafted built in bed. Mechanicals were thoughtfully replaced with a higher efficiency gas furnace and air conditioning and an On-Demand natural gas tankless water heater. And YES there is a two car detached garage for the auto enthusiast or those who want there own private space away from the house. This garage would make a perfect home shop for a hobbyist looking for an insulated and fully finished work space that happens to have its own 100 amp service with a window A/C unit. This home is a must see and will make the perfect next chapter for any family.

1131 S Harrison Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Fathom Realty. Selling Office: Fathom Realty.

$309,900
3 Beds 2 Baths
Off the beaten path but within walking distance of everything Morristown has to offer! Custom poured concrete walkway will lead you to the well maintained 3 bedroom 2 bath that awaits your personal touches. Cozy up to the gas log fireplace in the nice size living room that opens to the dining room area. Appliances are included in the at your fingertips kitchen. Almond colored cabinets and pantry will provide ample storage for all of your kitchen gadgets. Enjoy your morning coffee as you admire the backyard through the bowed window in the breakfast nook. Primary bedroom is complete with your own private bathroom and walk-in closet. An octagon hallway separates the 2 additional bedrooms with shared bathroom. Washer and dryer are included in the laundry room that will lead you to the garage. Drive up the concrete driveway to the finished garage with insulated garage door. Mechanical's of the home are in the garage for easy maintenance. Entertain on your new 19x16 composite deck with two locking gates. Storage shed has built in shelves and will accommodate your storage needs. Everyone needs a barn with a front porch to add some rocking chairs too. The heated finished barn has been sectioned into separate work areas. Two service doors and overhead door makes for easy access. Tree lined backyard provides privacy and you get free admission to watch the kids practice soccer and play football.

519 S Locust Street, Morristown

Listing courtesy of Listing Leaders North Central. Selling Office: RE/MAX Real Estate Prof.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative